European Commission to examine transfer pricing agreements between Apple, Starbucks and Fiat Finance and the Member States
In June of this year, the European Commission opened three investigations examining the correctness of decisions concerning the income taxes paid in Ireland, the Netherlands and Luxembourg by multinational corporations. This is the European Union's response to emerging reports of a significant understatement of the taxes paid in Europe by companies such as Apple, Starbucks and Fiat.
The EU Commissioner for Competition, Joaquin Almunia, stated that: “In the context of tight public budgets, it is particularly important that large multinational enterprises pay their fair share of tax revenues. Under the EU's state aid rules, national authorities cannot use measures allowing certain enterprises to pay lower taxes than they should if the tax rules were applied in a non-discriminatory and equal manner”.
The European Commission will conduct three separate investigations concerning the tax rulings confirming the transfer pricing agreements concluded between:
- Ireland and Apple Sales International and Apple Operations Europe,
- the Kingdom of the Netherlands and Starbucks Manufacturing EMEA BV, and
- the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg and Fiat Finance and Trade.
The preliminary findings indicate that the taxes paid by Apple in Ireland are much lower than the income tax rate applicable in that country, which is 12.5%. Last year's investigation conducted by a Senate committee in the USA established that the effective tax rate paid by Apple thanks to individual arrangements with the Irish government is 2% or even less. Representatives of Starbucks, for their part, testified during an inquiry conducted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom in 2012 that the group's agreement with the Netherlands had allowed it to enjoy a very low tax rate.
The European Commission will also examine the transfer pricing agreement applied by Luxembourg in relation to the Fiat company. Unlike Ireland and the Netherlands, that state provided the European Commission only with cursory information that did not contain the data requested. The European Commission has therefore issued a formal notice calling on the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg to remedy the infringement of the law (IP/14/309).
Algirdas Šemeta, Commissioner for Taxation and Customs Union, Audit and Anti-Fraud, said at a press conference in connection with the investigations opened: “Fair tax competition is essential for the integration of economies within the single market, for the stability of the Member States' finances and for equal opportunities for business. The European social and economic model depends on it, which is why everything possible must be done to defend it”.
