Planned amendments to the Tax Ordinance
The Ministry of Finance has submitted to the Standing Committee of the Council of Ministers, for consideration, the draft assumptions for a bill amending the Act – Tax Ordinance and certain other acts. The document describes changes that are to enter into force before the end of this year. Some of them concern Section IIa of the Tax Ordinance, which deals with agreements on the determination of transfer prices (“APA”).
As the Ministry of Finance explains, the amendment to the Tax Ordinance is needed in order to resolve practical problems urgently and to tighten tax collection. A comprehensive codification of general tax law is also necessary, which is to take place in the longer term.
The draft assumptions were the subject of broad and lengthy consultations between the Ministry of Finance and the social partners and business organisations, as well as other ministries. It should be noted, however, that some of the proposed solutions raise doubts on the part of the Government Legislation Centre and the Ministry of Economy – the differences will be resolved at later stages of the work.
The draft assumptions provide for an extension of the scope for issuing APAs by eliminating the restriction to transactions of a single type. The change also aims to remove interpretative doubts concerning the number of entities to which an APA relates, and abolishes the restrictions as to the subject matter and type of agreement. Provision has also been made for extending the scope for issuing APAs to include cost sharing agreements. The argument for extending the scope of APAs to agreements of this type is the publication by the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum of a report[1] containing guidelines and good practices for agreements of this type.
An important change is to be the replacement of the institution of extending the period of validity of a decision on an agreement with the institution of renewing the decision. The main reason for introducing such a solution is the wish to make it possible to update certain elements of a previously concluded agreement, provided that they do not constitute a material change in the conditions and that they result from the variability of the economic environment.
The above changes will make it necessary for the Minister of Finance to issue implementing acts describing three new types of application to be filed in respect of agreements on the determination of transfer prices. These will be:
1) an application for the conclusion of an agreement,
2) an application for the conclusion of a cost sharing agreement,
3) an application for the renewal of a decision on an agreement.
The legal provisions currently in force state that the period of validity of a decision begins on the date of its service. Unlike under the legislation of other countries, an APA decision issued in Poland therefore does not cover a past period. This state of affairs causes discrepancies in the period of validity of a bilateral or multilateral agreement concluded with the competent authority of another state. It was therefore decided to introduce a change extending the scope of the agreement to the period from the moment the application is filed.
In addition, the terms used in the Tax Ordinance in the context of related parties are to be aligned with the vocabulary used in the Corporate Income Tax Act and the Personal Income Tax Act.
[1] Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee on the work of the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum in the period July 2010 to June 2012 and related proposals: 1) report on small and medium enterprises and transfer pricing and 2) report on cost contribution arrangements on services not creating intangible property
