Estonia
Reference to the arm's length principle
Article 8(2) of the Estonian Income Tax Act (Related parties) provides that the difference between the price used in transactions between related parties (hereinafter: the transfer price) and the value of similar transactions carried out between independent parties (hereinafter: the market price) is taxed in accordance with the transfer pricing provisions (Article 14 [Business income], Article 50 [Income tax on dividends and other profit distributions], Article 53 [Taxation of a permanent establishment belonging to a legal person not resident in Estonia]), unless it constitutes a fringe benefit. Article 50(4) of the Estonian Income Tax Act (Income tax on dividends and other profit distributions) and Article 53(46) of the Income Tax Act (Taxation of a permanent establishment belonging to a legal person not resident in Estonia) stipulate, in line with the arm's length principle, that if the price of a transaction carried out with a related party by a resident legal person or by a non-resident having a permanent establishment in Estonia is not the market price, the tax liability covers both the income that the taxpayer could have earned and the costs that the taxpayer would not have incurred had the transfer price been consistent with the arm's length principle. A similar provision is contained in Article 14(7) of the Income Tax Act, which governs the taxation of income from business carried on by a sole proprietor.
References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines
The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines are not binding within the Estonian legal system. However, they have been translated into Estonian and, under Article 20 of the Regulation of the Minister of Finance (which entered into force on 1 January 2007), taxpayers and the tax administration are encouraged to use the OECD Guidelines in situations not provided for in the Regulation and to the extent that this does not conflict with the Regulation.
Definition of related parties
The definition of related parties is set out in Article 8 of the Income Tax Act, according to which parties are deemed to be related if they have common interests or if one of them has a dominant influence over the other. That Article also contains an illustrative list of related parties. Article 8 Related parties Parties are deemed to be related if they have common commercial interests or if one of the persons holds a dominant position in relation to the other. The following persons are always deemed to be related: spouses, partners in civil partnerships, persons related directly or by law, companies belonging to the same group, as that term is defined in Article 6 of the Commercial Code, a natural person and a legal person holding more than 10% of the shares in the capital, of the total number of votes or of the rights to a share in the profits of a legal person, legal and natural persons that, together with other persons related to them, hold more than 50% of the shares in the capital, of the total number of votes or of the rights to a share in the profits of a legal person, legal persons, if more than 50% of their share capital, number of votes or rights to a share in the profits belongs to one and the same person or to related persons, natural persons holding more than 25% of the share capital, of the total number of votes or of the rights to a share in the profits of one and the same legal person, legal persons whose management board members, or members of bodies substituting for the management board, are the same persons, an employer and an employee, the employee's spouse, partner or relative, a legal person and a member of its management board or controlling body (§ 9) or that member's spouse, civil partner or direct relative. The transfer pricing provisions also apply to transactions entered into by Estonian residents, by non-residents through a permanent establishment and by sole proprietors with any related person.
Transfer pricing methods
Regulation No 53 provides for five transfer pricing methods: the comparable uncontrolled price method, the resale price method, the cost plus method and the transactional profit methods, namely the profit split method and the transactional net margin method – these methods are the same as those in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines. There is no mandatory order in which these methods are to be applied. It is for the taxpayer to decide which method to choose, provided, however, that the choice is appropriate (justified).
Transfer pricing documentation requirements
For the purpose of applying the transfer pricing rules, a company resident in Estonia is required, at the request of the tax authorities, to provide additional information on transactions with related parties, on the activities of companies belonging to the same group and on the structure of that group. The tax authorities should grant the company a time limit of at least 60 days for providing the above information (Article 50, subparagraph 7 of the Income Tax Act). The requirements for submitting this information, as well as those concerning the methods for determining the value of transactions, are laid down in Regulation No 53. Additional documentation requirements for transactions with related parties are contained in Article 18 of that Regulation. These additional requirements are imposed on the following entities in the given situations: credit and insurance institutions and companies listed on a stock exchange that are resident in Estonia, in the case of transactions with related parties resident in countries and territories with low tax rates, where companies resident in Estonia and entities not resident in Estonia operating in its territory through permanent establishments, regarded as related parties, meet at least one of the following conditions: (1) they employ at least 250 employees, (2) their turnover in the financial year preceding the year of the transaction amounted to at least EUR 50 million, or (3) the total of their consolidated balance sheet amounts to at least EUR 43 million. The detailed documentation consists of two parts, namely: (a) the main part (documents containing standardised information common to all members of the group) and (b) documents containing information on the taxpayer's transactions carried out with individual related parties. For other taxpayers, the documentation requirements are optional and should be applied as recommendations.
Specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific transfer pricing penalties
There are no special audit procedures in the area of transfer pricing, nor penalties dedicated to this area. The law provides for penalties where tax is understated. The amount of the penalty depends on the type of conduct on which it is based – tax evasion by a legal person may cost it up to EUR 13,000 (under Article 153.1 of the Taxation Act), whereas tax fraud is punishable by up to EUR 32,000 (under Article 153.2 of the Taxation Act). Where time limits for actions to be taken vis-à-vis the tax authority are not observed (failure to submit a tax return, documents, annexes or other information, etc.), the fine may amount to up to EUR 3,200 (Article 154 of the Taxation Act). Knowingly providing false information in a tax return may also result in the initiation of criminal proceedings, in which the penalty may amount to up to EUR 16,000,000 (Article 44 of the Penal Code).
Relevant provisions on transfer pricing agreements (advance pricing agreements)
No data in the source material.
Links to relevant government websites
Ministry of Finance: Rahandusministeerium Tax and Customs Board: Maksu- ja Tolliamet
Other relevant information
1. Provisions of domestic law referring to the arm's length principle. 2. References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations in domestic law. 3. Domestic legislation or regulations containing a definition of related parties or associated enterprises. 4. Relevant legislation or regulations containing guidance on transfer pricing methods, including the order in which they are to be applied, if any. 5. Domestic provisions, if any, relating to transfer pricing documentation requirements. 6. Domestic provisions, if any, on specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific penalties relating to transfer pricing. 7. Domestic provisions, if any, on advance pricing agreements. 8. Website addresses of the competent authorities responsible for transfer pricing policy and its administration and for advance pricing agreements. 9. Other relevant information, for example data from substantive reviews or transfer pricing provisions currently in preparation.
Prepared on the basis of the following material; status as at 6 December 2012; own translation by Anna Jarecka.
