Russia
Reference to the arm's length principle
Article 40 of Part 1 of the Russian Tax Code (introduced on 17 July 1998, as subsequently amended) establishes the arm's length principle and introduces methods for determining market prices in controlled transactions. Although Article 40 makes no formal reference to the arm's length principle or to the range of arm's length conditions for related parties, Article 40.3 enables the tax authorities to impose additional tax and late-payment interest where the prices of goods, work or services applied by the parties in a controlled transaction deviate by more than 20% from the market prices of identical goods, work or services. Under Article 40.8, in order to determine the market price in a controlled transaction, the prices prevailing in transactions between unrelated parties should be taken into account. Under Article 40.2 of the Russian Tax Code, the list of controlled transactions comprises: transactions between related parties, barter transactions, foreign trade, and transactions in which the price has, within a short period, risen or fallen by more than 20% compared with the prices set by the taxpayer for identical or similar goods or services, work.
References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines
The Russian Tax Code contains no references to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines. Nor are there any specific regulations on the application of the transfer pricing provisions.
Definition of related parties
Article 20 of the Russian Tax Code contains a definition of related parties; it describes the following three situations: One party to the transaction holds a direct or indirect interest of more than 20% in the capital of the other party, One of the persons is subordinate to the other by virtue of the official positions they hold, The persons are linked by marriage, kinship, affinity, the status of adopter or adoptee of the other person, or the status of guardian of the other person or of being under that person's guardianship. In addition, under Article 20.2, the courts may deem parties to be related in situations other than those listed above as well, if that other relationship may affect the outcome of the transaction.
Transfer pricing methods
Articles 40.9 and 40.10 of the Russian Tax Code provide for the following methods, which may be used by the tax authorities to determine market prices: Comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method, Resale price method, Cost plus (“reasonable margin”) method. The above methods should be applied in accordance with their strict hierarchy, in which the comparable uncontrolled price method is the priority method. If it cannot be applied, the resale price method should be used, and as a last resort the cost plus method should be applied.
Transfer pricing documentation requirements
The Russian Tax Code does not introduce any obligations to document or report on transfer pricing matters. However, during a tax audit, the taxpayer may be asked to present additional documents concerning the calculation of the price in controlled transactions.
Specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific transfer pricing penalties
The Russian Tax Code contains no procedures for conducting a separate transfer pricing audit. The tax authorities examine the prices applied in the course of ordinary tax audits. The Tax Code does not provide for specific penalties attributable to transfer pricing matters; under Article 40.3 of the Tax Code, the tax authorities may only impose on the taxpayer additional tax and late-payment interest in the event of transfer pricing adjustments. Under Article 122 of the Russian Tax Code, an understatement of the tax assessment may result in a penalty of 20% of the unpaid tax being imposed on the taxpayer (this penalty may rise to 40% if bad faith and intent on the part of the taxpayer are proven).
Relevant provisions on transfer pricing agreements (advance pricing agreements)
The Russian Tax Code contains no provisions on advance pricing agreements.
Links to relevant government websites
Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation: http://www1.minfin.ru/ru/ Federal Tax Service: http://www.nalog.ru/
Other relevant information
In accordance with the main objectives of tax policy adopted by the Russian government for 2009-2011, new transfer pricing rules should enter into force at the turn of 2009-2010. In November 2007, the Russian Minister of Finance published on the website a draft of amendments to Part 1 of the Russian Tax Code, which is connected with the development of rules on the determination of transfer prices for tax purposes. According to that draft, the main planned changes are as follows: extension of the list of criteria under which enterprises may be deemed to be related, introduction of a broader application of the arm's length principle; the 20% deviation from market prices permitted hitherto will no longer be allowed, extension of the list of official sources of information, formal introduction of the following transfer pricing methods: a) the transactional margin method, b) the profit split method, c) the method of subsequent resale of the goods concerned, introduction of reporting obligations in respect of controlled transactions, introduction of documentation obligations in respect of transfer pricing. The new transfer pricing rules will be closer to the OECD Guidelines in this area than the provisions currently in force.
1. Provisions of domestic law referring to the arm's length principle. 2. References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations in domestic law. 3. Domestic legislation or regulations containing a definition of related parties or associated enterprises. 4. Relevant legal provisions or regulations containing guidance on transfer pricing methods, including the order in which they are applied, if any. 5. Domestic provisions, if any, relating to transfer pricing documentation requirements. 6. Domestic provisions, if any, concerning specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific penalties in respect of transfer pricing. 7. Domestic provisions, if any, on advance pricing agreements. 8. Website addresses of the competent authorities responsible for transfer pricing policy and its administration and for advance pricing agreements. 9. Other relevant information, for example data from substantive reviews or transfer pricing provisions currently in preparation.
Prepared on the basis of the following material; status as at 10 April 2009; own translation by Anna Jarecka.
