Italy
Reference to the arm's length principle
In Italian legislation, the arm's length principle is embodied in the concept of “normal value”. The relevant provisions are contained in the consolidated text of the Italian income tax provisions (Testo Unico delle Imposte sui Redditi, TUIR), Article 9, paragraphs 3 and 4, and Article 110, paragraph 7, of Presidential Decree No 917 of 22 December 1986. The transfer pricing provisions were issued in the early 1980s (Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 22 September 1980, No 32/9/2267; Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 12 December 1981, No 42/12/1587). It should be noted that in 2010 Italy adopted new rules on transfer pricing documentation (Article 26 of Decree-Law No 78 of 31 May 2010, the Decision of the Commissioner of the Italian Revenue Agency of 29 September 2010 and Circular No 58/E of 5 December 2010), which refer to the arm's length principle and, in their entirety, to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations of 22 July 2010. Extract from the TUIR Article 9 […] 3. Subject to the provisions of paragraph 4 as regards the goods referred to therein, normal value means the average price or consideration charged for identical or comparable goods or services in dealings conducted on market terms, at the same marketing stage and at the place and time at which the goods or services were acquired or, in the absence of such data, at the nearest time and place. In determining normal value, reference should be made, as accurately as possible, to the price list or tariff applied in trade, taking into account the discounts applied by distributors. In the case of goods and services subject to price control, the relevant provisions should serve as the point of reference. 4. The normal price is determined: (a) for shares, bonds and other securities listed on a domestic or international stock exchange, on the basis of the prices recorded in the last month, (b) for shares and for interests in companies other than shares, and for securities and interests in the capital of entities other than companies, in proportion to the net worth of that company or entity or, in the case of newly established companies or entities, in proportion to the amount of capital contributed to them, (c) for bonds and securities other than those referred to in points (a) and (b), by analogy with securities similar in nature to those listed on a domestic or international stock exchange. In the absence of such information, the price is determined on the basis of other objective data. Article 110 […] 7. Components of income arising from transactions entered into by an enterprise with non-resident companies which directly or indirectly control the enterprise, are controlled by the enterprise, or where the same persons participate in the control of both parties to the transaction, are assessed in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 2 of this Article, on the basis of the normal prices of the goods supplied, the services rendered and the goods and services purchased, if they give rise to an increase in taxable income. This provision should also be observed where taxable income is reduced, provided that this is consistent with agreements concluded with the participation of the relevant tax authorities on the basis of the bilateral procedures laid down in international conventions for the avoidance of double taxation. This provision also applies to goods and services supplied by non-residents on whose behalf the enterprise provides marketing, manufacturing or processing services.
References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines
The Decision of the Commissioner of the Italian Revenue Agency of 29 September 2010 and Circular No 58/E of 5 December 2010 refer expressly to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations of 22 July 2010.
Definition of related parties
The definition of related parties is set out in Circular No 32/9/2267 of 22 September 1980. For transfer pricing purposes, control is defined in such a way that it can be applied to any potential or actually occurring economic phenomena, depending on the circumstances.
Transfer pricing methods
The above-mentioned Decision of the Commissioner of the Italian Revenue Agency of 29 September 2010 and Circular No 58/E of 5 December 2010, in line with the principle aimed at identifying “the most appropriate transfer pricing method in the particular circumstances”, refer to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations of 22 July 2010.
Transfer pricing documentation requirements
Italy has introduced new documentation requirements which limit the risk of transfer pricing penalties being applied. The new provisions on documentation requirements were introduced by the Decision of the Commissioner of the Italian Revenue Agency of 29 September 2010 and are largely based on the European Union's guidance on transfer pricing (EU TPD 2006/c 176/01). Further guidance on documenting transactions with related parties is contained in Circular No 58/E of 5 December 2010.
Specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific transfer pricing penalties
Transfer pricing audits of large taxpayers are based on risk analysis.
Relevant provisions on transfer pricing agreements (advance pricing agreements)
Article 8 of Decree-Law No 269/2003 introduces arrangements (the so-called International Tax Rules) between the Italian tax administration and enterprises carrying on business at international level, concerning mainly, but not exclusively: transactions, transfer pricing, dividends, interest, royalties and other international matters. The relevant implementing rules were announced by the Italian Revenue Agency on 23 July 2004.
Links to relevant government websites
Ministry of Finance: www.finanze.gov.it Revenue Agency: www.agenziaentrate.gov.it Tax documentation knowledge base: http://dt.finanze.it/doctrib/SilverStream/Pages/DOCTRIBFrameset.html All websites are available in Italian only.
Other relevant information
Implementation of the provisions on the documents required for verifying the consistency of the transfer prices applied by multinational enterprises with the arm's length principle: http://www.agenziaentrate.gov.it/wps/wcm/connect/407e6800444f85af891ceb536ed3dbc9/ItalyCommissionerDecision_29_09_2010_transfer_pricing.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&CACHEID=407e6800444f85af891ceb536ed3dbc9 Guidelines on mutual agreement procedures based on Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention and on the EU Arbitration Convention: http://def.finanze.it/DocTribFrontend/getContent.do?rand=4672519228497197875
1. Provisions of domestic law referring to the arm's length principle. 2. References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations in domestic law. 3. Domestic legislation or regulations containing a definition of related parties or associated enterprises. 4. Relevant legislation or regulations containing guidance on transfer pricing methods, including the order in which they are to be applied, if any. 5. Domestic provisions, if any, relating to transfer pricing documentation requirements. 6. Domestic provisions, if any, on specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific penalties relating to transfer pricing. 7. Domestic provisions, if any, on advance pricing agreements. 8. Website addresses of the competent authorities responsible for transfer pricing policy and its administration and for advance pricing agreements. 9. Other relevant information, for example data from substantive reviews or transfer pricing provisions currently in preparation.
Prepared on the basis of the following material; status as at 22 October 2012; own translation by Anna Jarecka.
