Cash pooling and the obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation under Article 9a of the CIT Act
Cash pooling services are one of the tools for managing the financial liquidity of capital groups. They consist in optimising financial management by concentrating, in a joint group account, funds from the individual accounts of the particular entities belonging to the group. Using such a solution makes it possible to:
- offset temporary shortfalls of funds reported by some participants in the cash pooling service against surpluses achieved by other entities,
- minimise the overall costs of credit financing for the group's entities,
- optimise interest costs and interest income within the group.
Cash pooling is a mechanism known in many countries and frequently used by capital groups (although there is nothing to prevent this solution from being used by, for example, individual shops associated within a retail chain). Comprehensive regulations on cash pooling services have not, however, developed in Polish law.
An indirect reference to this institution is found in a regulation of the Council of Ministers[1], which imposes on residents settling accounts with non-residents under agreements on multilateral settlements within a capital group the obligation to inform the National Bank of Poland of the conclusion of contracts of this type and to submit quarterly reports on their performance.
Article 93a of the Banking Law Act[2], in turn, provides that a bank may conclude with companies forming a tax capital group (within the meaning of the provisions on corporate income tax), represented by the parent company of that group, an agreement consisting in the application of a consolidated interest rate to the funds held in the bank accounts of those companies and to the credits and cash loans granted to them.
The lack of more detailed regulations on cash pooling means that, in structuring it, it is necessary to rely on the provisions on freedom of contract (Article 353.1 of the Civil Code[3] et seq.) and on subrogation to the rights of a satisfied creditor (Article 518 of the Civil Code et seq.).
It should be noted that in cash pooling agreements the entity managing the system, i.e. the so-called Cash Pool Leader, may be either an entity from the capital group to which the participants in the system belong or an unrelated or related financial institution.
In the context of transfer pricing, cash pooling raises two fundamental questions:
- Do the mutual relations between the participants in a cash pooling settlement system give rise to a documentation obligation within the meaning of Article 9a of the CIT Act[4]?
- Do the services provided by the Cash Pool Leader to a group of related parties require transfer pricing documentation to be prepared in accordance with Article 9a of the CIT Act?
To answer the first question, it should be recalled that the documentation obligation applies to entities carrying out transactions with related parties or with residents of countries engaging in harmful tax competition. The key concept here, that of a transaction, has no statutory definition in either tax law or civil law. It is therefore reasonable to use the dictionary definition of the term, which reads as follows: “a transaction is a commercial operation concerning the purchase or sale of some goods or services”[5].
Until now, the tax authorities had unanimously taken the position that the mutual relations between entities using a cash pooling service cannot be regarded as a transaction in this sense, which means that participation in a cash pooling system does not give rise to an obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation[6]. Similarly, it was held that, where interest is paid between related parties using cash pooling services, one cannot speak of a transaction that would give rise to a documentation obligation[7]. This way of interpreting the transfer pricing provisions in relation to the cash pooling system has been confirmed in many tax rulings[8].
However, the most recent tax ruling, of 5 November 2013, concerning cash pooling in the context of transfer pricing contains the statement that “the provision [of Article 9a of the CIT Act] does not exclude the obligation to document transactions between related parties within cash pooling. Such documentation should contain the information that will be necessary to assess that the taxpayer participating in such an agreement obtains greater benefits (e.g. in the form of lower costs) than if it deposited funds with, and borrowed funds from, entities unrelated to it. At the same time, the documentation should show the equivalent nature of such an agreement. Furthermore, it should be pointed out that the [cash pooling] system meets the definition of a loan and therefore also constitutes a transaction within the meaning of the regulation under discussion. (…) Having regard to the content of the provisions cited and the information presented in the application, it must be concluded that, in connection with its participation in the cash pooling system, the company will be subject to the documentation obligation under Article 9a of the CIT Act if the transactions between its participants exceed, in a given tax year, the values specified in Article 9a(2) of that Act[9]”.
The above means that the documentation obligation concerning the mutual relations between participants in a cash pooling system must be determined individually, depending on the structure of the agreement concluded by the participants in such a system and on how it compares with market conditions. Despite many recurring voices, the position of the tax authorities on this matter is not unequivocal, which constitutes yet another controversy in the area of the taxation and formal obligations of companies using cash pooling.
Answering the second question, on the other hand, requires identifying the typical activities of the Cash Pool Leader. These include: initiating cash transfers, executing bank transfers, determining the amounts to be transferred, and calculating and settling interest. As a rule, it also has information on the financial and business plans of the entities it serves. All of the activities listed are consistent with the dictionary definition of a transaction.
Where the Cash Pool Leader is an entity related to the entities for which it provides services, the relation of its remuneration to the transaction thresholds specified in Article 9a(2) of the CIT Act determines whether transfer pricing documentation must be prepared.
It may also happen that the function of Cash Pool Leader is performed by a bank. Such an entity is usually not related to any of the participants in the system. Consequently, one of the basic conditions necessary for the obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation to arise is not met[10].
[1] Regulation of the Council of Ministers of 10 December 2002 on the manner, scope and time limits for the performance, by residents engaging in foreign exchange transactions with foreign countries, of the obligations to provide the National Bank of Poland with data to the extent necessary for the preparation of the balance of payments and the statements of the state's foreign assets and liabilities (Journal of Laws No. 218, item 1835).
[2] Banking Law Act of 29 August 1997 (Journal of Laws 1997 No. 140, item 939)
[3] Civil Code Act of 23 April 1964 (Journal of Laws 1964, No. 43, item 296).
[4] Corporate Income Tax Act of 15 February 1992 (Journal of Laws No. 21, item 86).
[5] Uniwersalny słownik języka polskiego, ed. S. Dubisz, PWN, Warsaw 2003
[6] IPTPB3/423-178/12-2/PM
[7] ILPB4/423-254/10-9/MC
[8] Cf. IPPB5/423-658/11-6/JC; ILPB3/423-938/10-2/GC; IBPBI/2/423-1763/10/CzP; IPPB5/423-84/11-4/JC; ITPB3/423-613b/09/DK; IBPBI/2/423-19/10/MS; IBPBI/2/423-484/10/SD; IPPB3/423-245/10-2/PD; ILPB4/423-18/10-7/ŁM; IPPB5/423-437/10-9/JC; ILPB3/423-650/10-7/MM.
[9] ILPB4/423-309/13-3/DS. This position was confirmed in the individual tax ruling issued by the Director of the Tax Chamber in Katowice on 1 July 2014 under reference IBPBI/2/423-372/14/MS.
[10] IBPBI/2/423-1101/12/MO
