Transfer pricing – disregard of the documentation obligation
In recent times, transfer pricing has been playing an ever greater role in the tax planning of related enterprises. This is connected with the constantly growing number of related parties operating not only on the domestic market but also on foreign markets. Consequently, the number of transactions concluded between these enterprises, which generate certain risks in the area of transfer pricing, is also growing.
Under the tax law regulations in force, taxpayers concluding transactions with related parties, whether domestic or foreign, are obliged by those provisions to prepare appropriate transfer pricing documentation. In this documentation, taxpayers provide the tax authorities with a range of information on the terms on which these transactions were concluded, indicating all the factors that may have influenced the manner in which those terms were set.
This documentation is a source of information on the functions performed by the parties to a given transaction, the assets employed and the risk borne in connection with its performance. It is also worth pointing out that, in this documentation, the taxpayer should confirm in an appropriate manner that the given transaction was concluded on arm's length terms. Nevertheless, proving the arm's length nature of settlements between related parties causes enterprises many difficulties and requires a multi-dimensional analysis of the specific features of the given transaction.
Unfortunately, however, taxpayers very often treat the obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation as a “necessary evil” and do not observe the principle of preparing the documentation on an ongoing basis. Such conduct may lead to a situation in which the taxpayer is not fully prepared for an audit by the authority of the transactions concluded with related parties. In some cases this may result in tax risk connected with the absence of such transfer pricing documentation or with its improper preparation.
Taxpayers habitually postpone the preparation of the transfer pricing documentation until later, while that so-called “later” in many cases never arrives. Yet under the provisions in force the taxpayer has 7 days to submit complete transfer pricing documentation to the tax authorities, counted from the date on which those authorities make the request. This shows, however, that in practice taxpayers very often play down the obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation, assuming that they will not be audited in this respect. They assume that, should such an audit nevertheless take place, they will manage to prepare the required documentation within 7 days. Unfortunately, they do not realise that preparing documentation that is reliable and meets the requirements laid down in the provisions is extremely complicated and practically impossible to accomplish in such a short period.
Moreover, in that time the taxpayer is unable to carry out appropriate, credible and reliable analyses and comparisons. At most, taxpayers will use the 7-day period to identify the transactions between related parties that took place in the given period, to establish their value, or to gather information on the other additional documents that should form part of the documentation, e.g. agreements, annexes to those agreements, invoices, orders, price lists, calculations, etc.
It should be noted that a tax authority arriving for an audit does not provide the taxpayer with precise information on the transactions for which it would like to examine the transfer pricing documentation. The authority's request concerns all the documents that the taxpayer ought to prepare for the transactions it concludes with related parties. It is therefore the taxpayer who bears the burden of correctly determining the documents and information to be submitted to the authority, together with identifying the relevant transactions. In many cases this may give rise to considerable difficulties, especially where the enterprise does not have clearly specified rules for the circulation of documents and the preparation of transfer pricing documentation. The absence of written transfer pricing rules in a given enterprise may mean that, in the event of an unexpected audit, the enterprise will not escape penal sanctions connected with the absence or unreliable preparation of such documentation.
By leaving the obligation to prepare the documentation until the moment of a possible audit, taxpayers generate considerable risk, exposing the entire enterprise to an additional assessment by the tax authority at the 50% tax rate in connection with the difference that may arise between the income declared by the taxpayer and that determined by the authorities. That is why it is so important for taxpayers to prepare the documentation on an ongoing basis and, already when concluding agreements with related parties, to bear in mind that the obligation to prepare transfer pricing documentation may also apply to them.
In view of the above, neglect in the area of transfer pricing may cause the enterprise additional problems and lead to expenditure connected with non-compliance with the specified requirements. Taxpayers very often believe that the transactions they conclude with related parties are safe and are concluded in accordance with the arm's length principle. Unfortunately, in practice it very often turns out that the agreements concluded and the remuneration set in them are not based on arm's length principles. The recommended course of action for taxpayers is therefore to prepare the transfer pricing documentation on an ongoing basis, and already at the time of concluding a transaction the taxpayer should bear the documentation obligation in mind. In addition, enterprises should have arguments confirming the arm's length nature of the transactions concluded with related parties and should manage the transfer pricing area of the enterprise in such a way as to carry out tax planning effectively.
