Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Archive›Comparability of transactions in developing countries

Comparability of transactions in developing countries

Archived materialThis text comes from an earlier version of the site and has not been updated. Some of the content describes the legal position before the 2019 amendment of the transfer pricing rules. Up-to-date discussions can be found in the knowledge base.

In March 2014 the OECD issued a document entitled “Transfer Pricing Comparability Data and Developing Countries”, which presents and discusses four possible approaches to addressing the concerns raised by developing countries about the lack of access to comparability data.

Applying the arm's length principle very often requires enterprises to examine whether the price and terms set in a transaction concluded between related parties correspond to the prices and terms that unrelated enterprises would have agreed between themselves. It should be pointed out that it is important for these transactions (controlled and uncontrolled alike) to be concluded on similar terms and in similar circumstances, taking into account the functions performed by the individual parties to the transaction, the assets employed and the risks borne.

The above shows that the comparability of transactions plays a very important role when related parties conclude transactions. Carrying out a comparability analysis will allow those entities to determine whether the prices they have set correspond to market conditions and whether adjustments need to be made in order to minimise the risk of concluding a transaction on terms that deviate from arm's length terms.

The OECD and member countries often express concerns about the availability and quality of financial data on transactions between unrelated parties that can be used for comparison. Moreover, these countries have particular difficulty in obtaining access to reliable data and information on the financial results of comparable activities of independent enterprises. Therefore, in order for a precise analysis to be carried out, developing countries must be given access to financial databases containing detailed information that enables related enterprises to carry out a reliable comparability analysis.

This problem is becoming ever more apparent because work is under way on amending Chapter V of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines. The amendments assume that the taxpayer should attach a benchmarking study to all transfer pricing documentation prepared.[1]

The four alternative approaches helpful in solving the problems indicated, as presented by the OECD in the document in question, are briefly discussed below:

The first approach provides for action to improve the range of information contained in commercial databases, followed by increasing developing countries' access to those databases, including access to comparability data on large independent enterprises operating in the territory of developing countries.

The second approach assumes the most effective possible use of sources of comparability data. To this end, the OECD recommends providing assistance and advice on the effective use of commercial databases and foreign comparability data for enterprises. The OECD points out, however, that enabling the use of foreign databases requires their reliability to be increased and an alternative approach to searching for comparability data.

The next approach, also known as the “sixth method”, is increasingly used, particularly in developing countries, and consists in identifying arm's length prices that can be arrived at without the need to refer to direct comparable data. This method assumes the use of available guidelines and guidance, the profit split method, supply chain analysis, safe harbour provisions and an assessment of the impact of efficiency and compliance with the arm's length principle.

In the last, fourth approach, the OECD draws attention to the possibility of using advance pricing agreements and mutual agreement procedures. This approach assumes a review of developing countries' experience in this area, the identification by them of the advantages and disadvantages of using these instruments, and the conduct of negotiations in order to resolve transfer pricing disputes.

The document published by the OECD should be regarded as a good starting point for action to solve the problems that developing countries face with regard to the comparability of transactions concluded by related enterprises. One should therefore be hopeful that over the next few years it will be possible to find effective ways of solving the problems and difficulties associated with effective transfer pricing management.

[1] More on this subject can be found in the text “Changes to Chapter V of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines”.