Tax proceedings at first instance
Tax proceedings give concrete form to audit proceedings: drawing on the irregularities previously found, the authority conducts proceedings aimed at issuing a decision that will determine the tax liability in the correct amount, thereby rejecting the amount of tax declared by the taxpayer. In the case of transfer pricing, tax proceedings are initiated ex officio by the tax authority, which serves on the party an order on the initiation of proceedings.
The tax authority conducts transfer pricing proceedings on the basis of the provisions of the CIT Act and of the Regulation on the determination of taxpayers' income by way of estimating the prices applied in transactions by those taxpayers. Under these provisions, the tax authority examines whether the taxpayer's income was earned on the basis of the market value of the subject of the transaction, properly recorded and attributed to the parties to the transaction.
Where the taxpayer submits the transfer pricing documentation (DPCT) together with a determination of the market value of the subject of the transaction based on the comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method, the resale price method or the reasonable margin (“cost plus”) method, then, provided that the reliability and objectivity of the data presented do not raise justified doubts, the tax authority determines the market value of the transaction using the method previously adopted by the taxpayer, unless the use of another method is manifestly more appropriate.
It should be emphasised that one of the overriding principles of tax proceedings is the principle of written form. This means that all matters are dealt with in writing. The tax authority is obliged to draw up a concise record of every act in the proceedings that is of material importance for the resolution of the case, unless the act has been otherwise recorded in writing. Records are drawn up in particular of hearings, inspections and expert examinations carried out with the participation of an employee of the tax authority.
A case requiring evidentiary proceedings should be dealt with without undue delay, but no later than within one month, and in the case of a particularly complicated matter – no later than within 2 months. Alongside the above time limits laid down in the tax provisions, account should also be taken of the time limits set out in the Act on Freedom of Economic Activity. It states that the total duration of audits of an entrepreneur in a calendar year may not exceed 8 weeks.
The final element of tax proceedings is the issue of a decision determining the tax arrears (reducing the loss), which under Polish tax law are due from the date of service of such a decision. Thus, the tax authority may issue a decision establishing the amount of the tax liability, as well as a decision discontinuing the proceedings. A decision issued by the authority of first instance may be appealed to the tax authority of second instance.
The consequence of this is the obligation to pay the tax determined irrespective of whether an appeal has been lodged with the authority of second instance or whether such a decision is later set aside. If payment is not made, the taxpayer must reckon with the costs of enforcement, which are pursued in parallel with the tax arrears.
