The arm’s length principle in Polish and international regulations
The international standard agreed by the OECD member countries should be used to determine transfer prices for tax purposes. It is set out in Article 9 of the OECD Model Tax Convention as follows[1]: “(…) where, as a result of the relationships, conditions are agreed or imposed which differ from those which independent entities would have agreed between themselves, and as a result the entity does not report income or reports income lower than that which would be expected if those relationships did not exist, the income of that entity and the tax due shall be determined without taking into account the conditions resulting from those relationships”[2].
The theoretical basis for examining transfer prices, generally accepted in tax legislation, is the principle referred to in English as the arm’s length principle, which, taken literally, means the “principle of the length of an arm”. Its substance is the requirement that, despite the relationships existing between the entities forming part of the structure of a multinational enterprise, those entities should act in their mutual dealings by “keeping the counterparty at arm’s length”, that is, at an appropriate distance. The essence of this principle is that economically related enterprises are placed under an obligation to shape, in their mutual commercial relations, all of the conditions – including above all the prices set in their mutual transactions – in the way in which independent enterprises competing with one another would have done. Since, in transactions between independent enterprises, the allocation of profits is determined by the market mechanisms of supply and demand, the examination of transfer prices will come down to establishing whether they correspond to market prices in comparable transactions. The tax authorities will therefore seek to answer the question of whether unrelated entities set, or would set, the same prices in identical or comparable circumstances[3].
The Polish tax authorities implemented the OECD regulations[4] on transfer pricing in the income tax act and introduced the documentation obligation in 2001. The arm’s length principle was reflected by the legislator in the concept of the market value[5] of the subject of the transaction, which we define as the value determined on the basis of a price established using the traditional transaction methods and the transactional profit methods. The direct reference to the methods indicates that, when determining the proper income from a transaction, the tax authorities will be compelled to compare it with the comparable income earned by independent entities. It is significant that the OECD regulations state that the issue of transfer pricing should not be confused with the issue of tax fraud or tax avoidance, even though transfer pricing policies may be used for such purposes[6]. Two conclusions follow from the position thus presented:
- a transfer pricing policy may be designed for the purpose of the tax optimisation of multinational enterprises, and
- when examining a transfer pricing policy, the concept of the transfer price should not be confused with fraud or circumvention of the law.
Putting the matter in this way is particularly important where the transfer pricing policy has been designed at the level of the group of companies, e.g. in the USA, and implemented in Polish companies. It often happens that the basic assumptions of the guidelines of other countries are not consistent with Polish realities and regulations. It should therefore be noted that the application of transfer pricing is a particularly complicated issue within large multinational enterprises operating in many tax systems. The existing differences in requirements may lead to an increased burden on multinational enterprises and, as a result, to higher operating costs in comparison with enterprises operating within only one tax jurisdiction[7].
Particular importance for transfer pricing in Poland therefore attaches to the principles for examining and preparing documentation of transactions between related parties, referred to by the OECD as the arm’s length principle, which means that enterprises should set prices in transactions in the way in which they would have been set between unrelated entities[8]. These principles are highly significant from the point of view of the design of transfer prices, because all the methods of estimating prices in transactions are based on comparability with independent entities in the given factual circumstances, with the possibility of appropriate adjustments.
[1] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, Paris 1995, p. G-1. [2] Translation after Sojak S., Baćkowski D., Polskie przepisy prawne z zakresu cen transferowych (article), Profesjonalny Serwis Podatkowy 05/2005. [3] Litwińczuk A., Opodatkowanie zysków przedsiębiorstwa międzynarodowych (article), Profesjonalny Serwis Podatkowy 05/2005. [4] OECD Tax Model Convention and OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations. [5] §3(2) of the Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 10 September 2009 on the manner and procedure for determining the income of legal persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws No. 160, item 1268). Hereinafter: RMF. [6] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines, p. I-1. [7] Sojak S., Baćkowski D., Ceny transferowe – aspekt podatkowy, Warsaw 2003, Dom Wydawniczy ABC, p. 58. [8] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, OECD 1995/1997, pp. I-1 to I-27.
