Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Archive›Explanation of the Minister of Finance on business restructuring between related parties

Explanation of the Minister of Finance on business restructuring between related parties

Archived materialThis text comes from an earlier version of the site and has not been updated. Some of the content describes the legal position before the 2019 amendment of the transfer pricing rules. Up-to-date discussions can be found in the knowledge base.

On 27 February 2014 an explanation of the current provisions on business restructuring appeared on the website of the Ministry of Finance (hereinafter: the MF Explanation). This document refers to the Regulation of the Minister of Finance on transfer pricing[1], amended in July last year, which included a chapter devoted to the issue of restructuring. The MF Explanation is based on the content of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines[2].

The study by the Minister of Finance clarifies the provisions of the Regulation as regards restructuring, defines a number of concepts connected with this phenomenon and provides practical guidance on preparing and examining the tax documentation relating to it. The MF Explanation constitutes a set of instructions that is useful both for taxpayers and for the auditing authorities.

The Minister of Finance agrees with the OECD’s position that business restructuring most often involves:

  • the transfer of something of significant value, e.g. intangibles,
  • the termination or substantial renegotiation of existing agreements, e.g. manufacturing or distribution agreements, a licence agreement or an agreement for the provision of services.

The process of restructuring the business of related parties involves a reallocation of the functions performed, the assets used and the risks assumed, and consequently of the profit earned by the entities taking part in the restructuring. The transfer of functions, assets and risks may take place only where the entity taking them over has the capacity actually to take them over.

The MF Explanation places emphasis on the need for the conditions under which the restructuring is carried out to be consistent with the arm’s length principle. This means that the conditions agreed or imposed between related parties as part of a business restructuring should be comparable with the conditions that independent entities would have agreed between themselves. Where a given transaction cannot be compared with another transaction carried out on the open market, comparability should be examined by checking whether independent entities would have agreed to the same conditions in similar circumstances.

The Minister of Finance indicated three key areas that should be analysed in connection with restructuring processes. These are:

  • The restructuring transactions (carrying out a functional analysis before and after the transaction)
  • The business reasons for carrying out the business restructuring and the benefits expected in connection with it, including synergies,
  • The options realistically available to both entities participating in the restructuring.

Attention should be drawn to the fact that the obligation to document restructuring transactions and the possibility of their being examined by the tax authorities existed before the amendment to the Regulation. The MF Explanation therefore applies both to transactions that are being planned and carried out and to those that took place before the provisions of the Regulation were changed. The publication of the MF Explanation on restructuring, meanwhile, is evidence of the tax authorities’ growing interest in this subject, and taxpayers should therefore expect intensified audits in the area of restructuring. If the tax authorities challenge the justification for the restructuring processes carried out by the taxpayer, this may result in an adjustment of income and the need to pay additional tax.

[1] Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 10 September 2009 on the manner and procedure for determining the income of legal persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws No. 160, item 1268). Hereinafter: the Regulation. [2] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, July 2010.