Shareholder costs and transfer pricing
The amendment to the Regulation of the Minister of Finance on transfer pricing (hereinafter: the Regulation)[1] introduced the concept of shareholder costs into its text. This issue had not previously been regulated in detail in the tax provisions on transfer pricing and therefore gave rise to many doubts. Only the Corporate Income Tax Act (hereinafter: the CIT Act)[2] contained a provision concerning such costs.
Article 16(1), points 38 and 38a, of the CIT Act indicates that such costs may not be a tax-deductible cost when calculating the amount of tax due. These provisions state that “expenses related to the provision of unilateral benefits to shareholders (stockholders) or members of cooperatives who are not employees within the meaning of separate provisions” do not constitute tax-deductible costs.
It follows that the following may be regarded as a tax cost:
- equivalent benefits of a bilateral nature, even if the shareholder (stockholder) is not an employee of the company – most often these are services provided by the shareholder (stockholder) to the company and described in a separate agreement,
- benefits of a unilateral nature, provided that the shareholder (stockholder) is employed by the company.
Before the amendment to the Regulation, when considering the issue of shareholder costs from the transfer pricing perspective it was necessary to rely on the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines[3]. Chapter VII of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines contained an explanation of the question of costs arising as a result of shareholder activity. It was explained that certain intra-group services may be provided to entities belonging to the group even if they do not report such a need and would not be willing to pay an independent enterprise for them. Such services are therefore performed for individual entities solely because of their membership of the group. These may be, for example:
- costs of activities relating to the legal structure of the parent company, such as: organising the general meeting of shareholders of the parent company, issuing shares in that company and the costs of the functioning of the supervisory board,
- costs relating to the parent company’s obligations as regards the presentation of balance sheets and activity reports, including consolidation reports at group level,
- costs of raising the resources needed by the parent company to acquire shares in another company.
The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines take the position that, in principle, there is no reason why entities should pay a related party (the shareholder) for this type of activity. In order to determine whether a given activity is classed as shareholder costs, it is necessary to examine whether, in comparable circumstances, an independent enterprise would be prepared to pay for the given service or would perform it itself.
The text of the Regulation in force until July 2013 contained only general indications concerning the allocation of costs incurred in creating intangible property. §23 stated that the amount of the charges borne by the taxpayer on this account could be regarded as consistent with the arm’s length principle where such costs would have been accepted by independent entities. This applied in particular to the proportional allocation of costs in relation to the expected benefits. An analysis of these provisions could lead to the conclusion that costs incurred by a shareholder in carrying out activities connected with a related party but not bringing that party any benefit (e.g. the preparation by the parent company of consolidated financial statements for the whole group) may not be passed on to that related party, because no independent enterprise would agree to such a charge.
The amended Regulation defines shareholder costs as “costs incurred by an entity holding shares (stock) in another related party which bring benefits exclusively to the entity holding shares (stock) in the other related party”. In order to make it easier to identify costs that may be regarded as shareholder costs, the legislator introduced into the Regulation Annex No. 2, containing an illustrative list of such costs. It is intended to assist taxpayers and representatives of the tax administrations. It should be noted, however, that not all of the costs listed in Annex No. 2 should automatically be classified as shareholder costs. It may happen that certain activities undertaken by the shareholder may bring a benefit to the taxpayer. Each situation should therefore be approached individually, and the catalogue of shareholder costs presented in the Regulation should be treated as guidance rather than as an exhaustive list that is simple to apply.
The Regulation linked the concept of shareholder costs with low value-adding services[4]. These were defined as “services of a routine nature, supporting the core business of the service recipient, generally or readily available, which do not contribute to the creation of high added value for the service provider or the service recipient”. This type of service was taken to include most standard intra-group services, such as: accounting and IT support, and marketing, legal and management services.
The amendment to the Regulation imposed on taxpayers an obligation to prepare descriptions of transactions concerning low value-adding services. Such a description should also include a list of the shareholder costs incurred in connection with the provision of such a standard service. This follows from the fact that “the costs related to the low value-adding services performed include costs directly and indirectly related to the service provided, excluding shareholder costs”. Shareholder costs should therefore be left out of the calculation of the remuneration for the low value-adding services provided.
Before the definition of shareholder costs was introduced into the Regulation, Polish tax provisions contained no direct references to this type of cost. The introduction of provisions regulating this matter should therefore be regarded as a positive change. However, the appearance of this concept in the context of transfer pricing may bring about a change in the tax authorities’ approach to auditing the costs incurred in purchasing intra-group services. In addition, the indication in the provisions of a catalogue of such costs may entail consequences for taxpayers in the form of the need to revise the transfer pricing policies they apply.
There is a likelihood that, when carrying out a transfer pricing audit at a taxpayer, the tax administration will automatically exclude from tax-deductible costs and from the calculation of remuneration all costs that could qualify for any of the cost categories listed in Annex No. 2. The taxpayer should therefore protect itself against such an eventuality and obtain in advance from the parent company appropriate information and documents confirming that it is not being charged with costs relating only to the shareholder. Such documents may, for example, present a description of the group’s standards as regards the allocation of costs and the creation and application of allocation keys.
[1] Regulation of the Minister of Finance on the manner and procedure for determining the income of legal persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws of 2009, No. 160, item 1268, as amended). Identical changes were also introduced into the analogous regulation concerning natural persons: the Regulation of the Minister of Finance on the manner and procedure for determining the income of natural persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws of 2009, No. 160, item 1267, as amended).
[2] Corporate Income Tax Act of 15 February 1992 (Journal of Laws No. 21, item 86).
[3] OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, Paris 2010 (hereinafter: the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines).
[4] More on this subject in the article available here.
