Low value-adding services
One of the more important changes introduced by the amendment to the Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 10 September 2009 on the manner and procedure for determining the income of legal persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws No 160, item 1268)[1] is the addition of a provision governing matters connected with low value-adding services. The purpose of this amendment is to take account, in the Polish legal regulations relating to transfer pricing, of the conclusions presented in the Communication from the European Commission of 25 January 2011 on the work of the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum as regards verifying whether the terms of such services are at arm's length.
Under the newly added provision in §22a, where a related party presents to the tax authorities or the fiscal control authorities a description of a transaction concerning low value-adding services, those authorities are obliged to examine the terms agreed by those parties for the given type of transaction on the basis of the description submitted. As part of that examination, the authorities verify whether independent parties acting rationally would have concluded such a transaction on the terms agreed by the related parties.
The provision goes on to define low value-adding services as services of a routine nature which support the main business of the service recipient, are generally or readily available, and do not generate significant added value for either the service provider or the service recipient. In addition, Annex No 1 to the Regulation sets out an illustrative catalogue of low value-adding services covering, for example, IT services, services connected with human resources management, marketing services, legal services, accounting and administrative services, technical services and services connected with quality control.
A taxpayer wishing to take advantage of the new solutions proposed by the legislator as regards the priority given to the description of low value-adding services may submit to the competent authorities an appropriate description, which should include in particular:
- an indication of the type of service provided, together with the justification for classifying the service as a low value service;
- confirmation that the service was performed, and a detailed explanation of the rationale for acquiring the services and of the benefits obtained;
- a description of, and justification for, the manner in which the services are provided;
- a list of the expenditure incurred by the related parties in connection with the services provided, together with its description and analysis;
- a list of shareholder costs;
- a description of the cost allocation key;
- a catalogue of on-call services, together with their description;
- an indication of the manner of calculating the remuneration due for the services provided and its amount, together with the justification for the method applied and for the manner of its application;
- the documentation that can be made available.
It is worth noting that the new provisions of the Regulation also provide that, once the taxpayer has presented the description of the transaction to the tax authorities or the fiscal control authorities, those authorities retain the right to request additional explanations and documents from the taxpayer.
Within §22a, the legislator has also introduced, in its subsequent subsections, a definition of shareholder costs. It has indicated that the expenditure connected with the performance of low value-adding services comprises the costs directly and indirectly connected with the service provided, to the exclusion of shareholder costs. According to the wording of §22a, shareholder costs are to be understood as expenditure incurred by an entity holding shares in another related party which benefits solely the entity holding shares in that other related party.
For shareholder costs, too, the legislator has provided an illustrative catalogue of such expenditure (constituting Annex No 2 to the Regulation), in which it presents, for example, the costs of activities connected with the legal structure of the shareholder, the costs relating to that entity's reporting, the costs of raising funds for the acquisition of shares, the costs of managerial and control (monitoring) activities connected with the management and protection of the investment in shareholdings, the costs of the initial listing of the entity on a stock exchange, and the costs connected with the investor relations of the entity holding shares in another related party.
Naturally, the manner in which the costs incurred by related parties in connection with the provision of low value-adding services are to be allocated should be analysed on the basis of the terms that unrelated parties would have agreed between themselves. Accordingly, the overriding principle in the case of transactions concluded between related parties concerning low value-adding services is the arm’s length principle.
The changes introduced should be regarded as favourable to the taxpayer, since a detailed description of the services prepared by the taxpayer and meeting the requirements indicated above will enable the taxpayer to prepare properly for an audit in this respect. Moreover, thanks to the precise description submitted by the taxpayer, the authorities will be able to prepare better for the audit and to carry it out more efficiently.
Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that the elements which, according to the legislator, the description of those services should contain may present an additional challenge for taxpayers and cause difficulties in preparing it correctly. Furthermore, the legislator has not specified, either in the provisions of the Regulation or in the tax acts, whether a taxpayer preparing a description of a transaction involving a low value-adding service should have regard to the value thresholds. Doubts may arise as to when the obligation to prepare such a document arises. It has not been clarified whether the condition for preparing the description is the exceeding of the thresholds indicated in the provisions of Article 9a of the CIT Act and, correspondingly, Article 25a of the PIT Act, or the mere fact that a low value-adding transaction has occurred.
It should also be noted that, when the provisions of the new Regulation are compared with the conclusions of the European Commission, the Polish legislator has not addressed the range of margins constituting a mark-up on the costs generated by low value-adding services that should be regarded by the authorities as being at arm's length. According to the Commission's Communication, the comments on the mark-up state that, in cases where a mark-up is to be applied, it will usually be modest. The mark-ups typically agreed fall within a range of 3 to 10%, and most often hover around 5%. Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that such a statement depends on the facts and circumstances, which may justify a different mark-up.
In our assessment, the changes introduced by the Minister of Finance should be regarded as positive, since they minimise the risk of low value-adding services being challenged by the tax authorities. They make the provisions on the specific solutions concerning these services more precise. Moreover, the amendment to the provisions of the Regulation does not generate a significant burden for the taxpayer as regards the documentation obligation. Thanks to the new provisions of the Regulation, the taxpayer will be able to present to the authorities a full and exhaustive description of a transaction concerning low value-adding services.
[1] Identical changes were introduced to the Regulation of the Minister of Finance of 10 September 2009 on the manner and procedure for determining the income of natural persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of natural persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws No 160, item 1267).
