Loan transactions and the documentation obligation
The granting of a loan is one of the transactions most frequently concluded by related parties. These enterprises enter into mutual transactions consisting in financing their activity by means of intra-group loans.
Under Article 9a of the Corporate Income Tax Act (hereinafter: the CIT Act), a taxpayer is required to prepare tax documentation for transactions concluded with related parties. The obligation referred to above covers a transaction or transactions between related parties in which the total amount (or its equivalent) resulting from the agreement, or the total amount of the benefits due in the tax year that was actually paid in the tax year, exceeds the equivalent of the thresholds indicated in that provision. It is worth explaining that, in order to determine the transaction threshold for loans, the threshold of EUR 30,000 should be used (Article 9a(2)(2) of the CIT Act), because it is applied in the case of the provision of services, and a loan agreement should be classified as a financial service.
What raises the greatest doubts among taxpayers is the value to be taken into account in determining whether the threshold triggering the obligation to prepare the said tax documentation has been exceeded. This is because there are different interpretations in this respect, according to which only the interest, or the principal, or the principal and the interest should be taken into account.
In the case of a loan, the form of remuneration for the parties to the transaction making capital available for a specified period is interest. Unlike the principal amount of the loan (which is repayable), interest constitutes a definitive increase in the lender's assets.[1] Accordingly, when determining the tax obligation for a loan transaction, one should be guided by the total amount of interest resulting from the agreement concluded between the related parties.
The position presented above is confirmed by the tax authorities in the individual tax ruling of the Director of the Tax Chamber in Warsaw of 7 October 2011, in which he indicates that “(…) as regards the preparation of tax documentation for the purposes of Article 9a(2) of the Corporate Income Tax Act – where, in the course of business activity, an interest-bearing loan is granted to another legal person that is a related party, only the amount of interest on the loan, as payment for granting it, should be taken into account as the value of the transaction (…)”.[2] Thus, in accordance with the above, when determining the value of the transaction the taxpayer should take into account only the amount of interest.
Nevertheless, it is also worth bearing in mind the opinions of authorities which take the position that, for the purposes of preparing tax documentation, the value of a loan transaction should be taken to be the loan principal together with the interest. This was the position taken by the Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz in the individual tax ruling of 5 January 2011.[3]
The authority indicates that the tax documentation should, among other elements, also contain a description of the benefits expected by the taxpayer in connection with the receipt of intangible services. A taxpayer concluding such an agreement with a related party should above all consider the purposefulness of concluding it. The expected benefits will therefore in this case relate to the proportionality between the cost of interest and the potential revenue obtained in connection with taking out the loan.
Unfortunately, as in many other cases, the authorities are not in agreement in their positions on the correct determination of the documentation obligation for loan transactions either. However, the practice of the last few years shows that they lean towards the position that, in determining the value of the transaction, only the value of the interest should be taken into account.
This is because the receipt of capital by a related party is tax-neutral, which means that the amount transferred to the entity receiving the loan does not constitute a definitive increase in its assets (provided that the loan has actually been repaid).
For although in the case of a loan – from the legal point of view – ownership of a specified amount of money is transferred to the borrower, nevertheless, from the economic and tax point of view, we are dealing with a “right to use another's property”, the payment for which is interest. In the case of transactions consisting in the granting of a loan, the transaction value to be adopted for the purposes of determining the obligation to prepare tax documentation is the value of the interest resulting from the agreement.
It should be recalled that, when preparing tax documentation for loan transactions, one should rely on a comparison of the conditions agreed between related parties with the conditions applied by independent entities. Consequently, the proper selection of the data used to establish the arm's length nature of the commission for the loan granted and of its interest rate is very important.
To sum up, in line with the rulings presented above, there are many doubts as to the documentation obligation for loan transactions. This is because the tax provisions do not specify precisely how the taxpayer should approach the determination of the transaction value. Nevertheless, guided by the arguments cited, when determining the value to be taken into account in establishing the transaction threshold for loans, the taxpayer should take into account solely the value of the interest.
[1] Marcin Jamroży, Dokumentacja podatkowa cen transferowych, ed. Dr M. Jamroży, Wydawnictwo ODDK, Gdańsk 2010, pp. 347-349 [2] Ref. IPPB5/423-677/11-2/AS [3] ref. ITPB3/423-548/10/MK
