Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Archive›Business restructuring in the light of transfer pricing regulations

Business restructuring in the light of transfer pricing regulations

Archived materialThis text comes from an earlier version of the site and has not been updated. Some of the content describes the legal position before the 2019 amendment of the transfer pricing rules. Up-to-date discussions can be found in the knowledge base.

The Regulation of the Minister of Finance on transfer pricing[1] (hereinafter: the Regulation), in force since July 2013, contains provisions on business restructuring. This issue was introduced into the Regulation in order to bring it into line with the new wording of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines[2], as revised in 2010. Through the introduction of the relevant provisions in the Regulation, transactions relating to the restructuring of an enterprise are treated like any other transactions concluded between related parties.

Business restructuring is the sum of complex processes and actions aimed at strengthening the competitive position of an enterprise, improving its economic results and increasing the value of the enterprise[3]. Restructuring activities may include transactions such as in-kind contributions, mergers and acquisitions, the separation of responsibility centres[4], the transfer of part of the business to another unit (domestic or foreign), and the renegotiation of the terms of existing arrangements.

The Regulation contains a definition of restructuring that is broad enough to cover many types of business transaction. The legislator stated that: “restructuring of business activity (…) shall mean the transfer between related parties of economically significant functions or assets or risks”.

The introduction of provisions on business restructuring into the Regulation gave rise to several controversies. The most important of these concerns doubts as to whether transfer pricing documentation describing restructuring activities should be prepared. The Regulation does not, after all, indicate unambiguously how transactions of this type should be treated.

An additional difficulty in this context is the structure of the CIT provisions imposing the documentation obligation on the taxpayer. That obligation refers to the concept of a transaction, which has no statutory definition. This gives the tax authorities a certain latitude in assigning to this category economic events that do not fit the classic dictionary definition[5] of the term. For that reason, a somewhat broader definition should be used with regard to the issue under discussion, if only because the legislator deliberately placed the provisions on restructuring in the Regulation, which allows it to be presumed that restructuring activities are to be treated in the same way as all other transactions between related parties.

For the purposes of the processes that make up business restructuring, transactions can be defined as a series of interrelated actions and activities resulting in the achievement of the intended commercial, economic or legal objectives. In other words, a transaction is an operation carried out in order to create, change or transfer particular tangible or intangible rights. It is therefore recommended that transfer pricing documentation be prepared, at least until a uniform practice of the tax administration develops in this area.

The provisions on restructuring contained in Chapter 5a of the Regulation are drafted in very general terms. They state only that the fiscal control authorities will examine whether the terms agreed or imposed as part of a restructuring of business activity between related parties are consistent with the terms that independent entities would have agreed between themselves. The examination is to concern, in particular, the right to remuneration and its value. There are, however, no specific guidelines, either for the tax authorities or for taxpayers themselves, as to what such an examination should look like and what exactly it should consist of.

The legislator indicated only that, in the course of the examination, the fiscal authorities will take into account the economic reasons for restructuring the business, the benefits expected from it and the realistic options available to the related parties taking part in the restructuring. This suggests a change in the nature of the examination from formal and legal to financial and economic, which may pose an additional difficulty for the fiscal authorities. It is, after all, difficult to assess the economic conditions prevailing in the past (i.e. at the time the transaction began) and the objective knowledge of them held by the entities taking part in the restructuring. Moreover, the elements indicated by the legislator are fairly subjective, which may give rise to disputes with taxpayers who disagree with the decisions issued by the fiscal authorities after the examination. Doubts may also be raised by the possibility of the fiscal authorities challenging the economic sense of a restructuring, since this interferes with the sphere of economic freedom and the freedom to shape relations between entities operating on the market as they see fit.

Another problem connected with the new provisions is the additional burden placed on taxpayers who restructured their enterprise in the past, but no earlier than five years ago. Such transactions are not yet time-barred, so in the event of an audit conducted by the fiscal authorities, the latter may demand the presentation of documentation describing the restructuring processes.

The amendments to the Regulation consisting in the addition of a chapter on the restructuring of business activity cannot be assessed unequivocally. On the one hand, they are a further step towards aligning the Polish transfer pricing rules with the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines; on the other, unclear, general provisions leave room for disputes with the fiscal authorities where a decision unfavourable to the taxpayer is issued.

On 27 February 2014, an explanation of the current provisions on business restructuring appeared on the website of the Ministry of Finance. The document refers to the Regulation of the Minister of Finance on transfer pricing, amended in July of last year, and is based on the content of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines.

[1] Regulation of the Minister of Finance on the manner and procedure for determining the income of legal persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws of 2009, No. 160, item 1268, as amended). Identical amendments were also introduced into the analogous regulation concerning natural persons: the Regulation of the Minister of Finance on the manner and procedure for determining the income of natural persons by way of estimation and on the manner and procedure for eliminating double taxation of legal persons in the event of an adjustment of the profits of related parties (Journal of Laws of 2009, No. 160, item 1267, as amended).

[2] Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, OECD, Paris 2010 (hereinafter: the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines).

[3] More information on business restructuring can be found here.

[4] An article on responsibility centres can be found here.

[5] According to the PWN Dictionary of the Polish Language (Słownik języka polskiego PWN), a transaction is “a commercial operation concerning the purchase or sale of goods and services” (http://sjp.pwn.pl//)