Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Archive›Transfer Pricing Comparability and Developing Countries

Transfer Pricing Comparability and Developing Countries

Archived materialThis text comes from an earlier version of the site and has not been updated. Some of the content describes the legal position before the 2019 amendment of the transfer pricing rules. Up-to-date discussions can be found in the knowledge base.

In March 2014 the OECD published the document “Transfer Pricing Comparability Data and Developing Countries”, which sets out four possible approaches addressing the concerns raised by developing countries about the lack of access to comparability data.

The ongoing work on amending Chapter V of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines assumes that the taxpayer should attach a benchmarking study to all transfer pricing documentation prepared. However, the OECD and its member countries often have doubts about the availability and quality of financial data on transactions between unrelated parties that can be used for comparisons. They also have considerable difficulty in gaining access to reliable data and information in the form of the financial results of comparable activities of independent enterprises.

For a precise analysis to be possible, developing countries need to be given access to financial databases containing detailed information that allows associated enterprises to carry out a reliable comparability analysis. The publication discusses four alternative approaches, presented by the OECD in the document referred to, that are helpful in resolving the problems indicated:

  • The first approach provides for action to improve the range of information contained in commercial databases. The next step is to increase developing countries' access to those databases, including access to comparability data on large independent enterprises operating in the territory of developing countries.
  • The second approach assumes the most effective possible use of sources of comparability data. To this end, the OECD recommends providing assistance and advice on the effective use of commercial databases and of foreign comparability data for enterprises. The OECD points out, however, that enabling the use of foreign databases requires their reliability to be increased and an alternative approach to searching for comparability data.
  • A further approach, also known as the “sixth method”, is increasingly used, particularly in developing countries, and consists in identifying market prices that can be arrived at without the need to refer to direct comparable data. This method assumes the use of available guidelines and guidance, the profit split method, supply chain analysis, safe harbour rules, and an assessment of the impact of efficiency and of compliance with the arm's length principle.
  • In the last, fourth approach, the OECD draws attention to the possibility of using advance pricing agreements (APA) and mutual agreement procedures. This approach assumes a review of developing countries' experience in this area, their identification of the advantages and disadvantages of using them, and the conduct of negotiations in order to resolve transfer pricing disputes.

The material published by the OECD should be regarded as a good starting point for action to resolve the problems that developing countries face with regard to the comparability of transactions concluded by associated enterprises. There is therefore reason to be optimistic that, over the next few years, effective ways will be found to resolve the problems and difficulties associated with managing transfer pricing effectively.

Transfer Pricing Comparability Data and Developing Countries