Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org

Argentina

Published:
Archived materialThis overview describes the regulations as they stood on the date it was prepared and has not been updated. The national rules in force may have changed since then.

Reference to the arm's length principle

In 1998, the Income Tax Law was amended by the enactment of Law No. 25.063 (effective for transactions entered into from 31 December 1998). The amendment introduced into the Income Tax Law updated transfer pricing provisions that are largely consistent with the OECD Guidelines adopted by many countries. Subsequently, the Income Tax Law was amended with respect to transfer pricing by the enactment of Law No. 25.239, published in the Official Gazette on 31 December 1999, and by the subsequent Decree N° 1037/2000. Article 14 of the Income Tax Law expressly refers to the arm's length principle, under which transactions between domestic enterprises (or branches of multinational groups located in Argentina) and foreign related parties are treated as transactions between independent parties if they are undertaken on arm's length terms. Where such transactions are not carried out on arm's length terms, the results achieved through them may be adjusted in accordance with the provisions of Article 15 of the Law. In addition, when, among others, Article 15 was introduced into the Income Tax Law, the provisions on combating ‘tax havens’ also became more restrictive, at least in so far as they concern transfer pricing. In this sense, the Australian rules (against which no objection may be raised and no showing made as to whether related parties are involved) deem that transactions entered into by local taxpayers with persons or entities registered or domiciled in low-tax countries will not be regarded as carried out on arm's length terms. It will therefore be necessary to apply a transfer pricing method in order to justify the value of the transactions carried out with such entities. Finally, with the enactment of Law No. 25.784, published in the Official Gazette of 22 October 2003, modifications were introduced into the transfer pricing regime relating to the treatment of import and export transactions in goods carried out by unrelated parties. Prior to this amendment, such transactions were in some cases subject to the obligation to apply transfer pricing methodology. The above-mentioned provisions introduced a new methodology for determining transfer prices in transactions involving the export of goods with a known price on the international market (this issue is addressed in point 4).

References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines

Argentina makes no reference in its tax regulations to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that five comparability factors have been added to the implementing decree to the Income Tax Law which, in their scope, are consistent with those set out in the Guidelines.

Definition of related parties

The Income Tax Law provides that an enterprise, trust or permanent establishment located or registered in Argentina and a person, entity or permanent establishment located or registered abroad will be regarded as related parties if they are directly or indirectly managed or controlled by the same entity by reason of its participation in capital, its level of credit balance, or its functional influence or influence of any other nature – contractual or otherwise – and that entity has the power to decide, direct or determine the business or activities carried on by the said companies, establishments or entities of another kind. For its part, the tax administration has developed guidelines for establishing the existence of a relationship between entities. In this sense, a transaction will be regarded as carried out by related parties if at least one of the conditions set out below is met: An entity holds all or the majority of the capital of another entity, With respect to two or more entities, alternatively: The same entity holds all or the majority of the interests in the capital of two other entities, The same entity holds all or the majority of the interests in the capital of one or more entities and also has significant influence over those other entities, The same entity simultaneously has significant influence over other entities. An entity holding the majority of votes necessary to form social ties within the enterprise or to prevail at the shareholders' meeting, Two or more entities have common directors, senior employees or managerial staff, An entity has the exclusive capacity to act as agent, distributor or dealer for the purchase or sale of goods, services or rights of another entity, An entity provides the technical equipment or technical know-how that constitutes the basis for the functioning of another entity whose business it manages. This must necessarily be technology without which the business of that entity could not be developed, i.e. technology that is indispensable for the performance of the activities concerned, An entity participates with another entity in associations without legal personality, such as temporary joint ventures, economic cooperation groupings or groupings of another kind, through which associations significant influence is exerted on the prices set, An entity agrees with another entity contractual clauses that are preferential in relation to those used in similar circumstances in dealings with third parties. Preferential terms include, among others, discounts according to negotiated volumes, financing of operations or payment for delivery. An entity participating significantly in setting the enterprise's strategy, e.g. with regard to the supply of materials and raw materials, production and sales, and other areas of the enterprise, An entity developing an activity that is significant only in relation to another entity, or whose existence is justified only by its relationship with that other entity (e.g. acting as ‘sole supplier’ or ‘sole customer’), An entity provides a key form of financing necessary for the development of another entity's business activity, by granting loans or guarantees and sureties of any kind, An entity assumes the losses or expenses of another entity, The directors, senior employees or managerial staff receive instructions from another entity or act in its interest, Under special agreements, circumstances or situations, the management or administration of an entity is entrusted to an entity holding a minority interest in the share capital.

Transfer pricing methods

Argentine legislation contains provisions on the methods used to determine whether a transaction between related parties was conducted in accordance with the arm's length principle. Article 15 of the Income Tax Law stipulates that the method or methods most appropriate to the type of transaction concerned must be used. Accordingly, the said article provides that the methods that may be applied are: the comparable uncontrolled price method, the resale price method, the cost plus method, the profit split method and the transactional net margin method – the form of which has been laid down in the relevant regulations. For its part, the tax administration has implemented provisions on this matter by issuing a regulation indicating that, on the basis of general and theoretical principles, the most appropriate way of determining whether transfer prices are consistent with the market prices applied between independent parties is the one that best reflects the economic reality of the transaction, and the regulation contains only some of the factors to be taken into account for this purpose. The regulation indicates that the best method will be the one which: best fits the structure of the business and the sales market, is supported by information of adequate quality justifying the application of that method, ensures the highest level of consistency between transactions entered into by related parties and those entered into by unrelated parties, and with respect to the entities taken into account in such a comparison, requires the fewest adjustments in order to eliminate differences between the facts and situations compared, The methods adopted by Argentine legislation for verifying transfer prices are similar to those set out in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations. The definitions of the statutory methods are as follows: Comparable uncontrolled price: the price that would have been agreed in a transaction with an independent party or between such independent parties in a comparable transaction. Resale price: the price for the acquisition of goods, the provision of a service or any other transaction between related parties, which should be determined by multiplying the resale price, or the price of the services or of any other transactions comparable with the transaction under review carried out by independent parties, by the difference between unity and the gross profit margin percentage agreed with or between independent parties to comparable transactions. For this purpose, the gross profit margin percentage should be calculated by relating gross profit to net sales revenue. Cost plus: this price results from multiplying the cost of the goods, services or other transactions by the result of adding to unity the gross profit percentage applied with or between independent parties to comparable transactions. The margin should be calculated as the ratio of gross profit to the cost of goods sold. Profit split: the profit from a transaction between related parties is divided between the parties to the transaction in the proportion that independent parties would have established in a comparable transaction. This is done in accordance with the following procedure: The total profit is determined as the result of adding together the profits allocated to each related party involved in the transaction. The total profit so obtained is assigned to each related party in the proportion resulting from taking into account the assets employed by each party and the costs and expenses incurred by them in connection with the transaction. Transactional net margin: the profit margin applied in transactions between related parties is determined by establishing the profit that would have been earned by the parties to the transaction had the transaction not been carried out with a related party. For the purposes of determining the said margin, profitability factors such as return on assets, sales, costs, expenses and cash flows may be taken into account. In addition, it is worth mentioning that Article 15.6, which relates to the above, also contains rules on new methods used for transfer pricing purposes in the case of export transactions to related parties involving goods such as: cereals, oilseeds, other products of the land, hydrocarbons and their derivatives, where an international broker other than the actual recipient of the goods is involved in those transactions. The best method for estimating Argentine-source income is the commercial value of the goods on the market on the day on which the goods are shipped, irrespective of the means of transport and regardless of the price agreed with the international broker. However, if the price previously agreed with the international broker was higher than the effective commercial value of the goods at the date of shipment, that price will be treated as the current value of the goods. The method described above should not be applied where the taxpayer proves that the international broker has met the following requirements: It must have a genuine presence in the territory of residence, where its commercial premises are located and where the business is conducted, and must comply with all legal requirements regarding registration and the filing of financial statements. The assets, risks and functions of the international broker must, in turn, be consistent with the volume of turnover; Its principal activity should not consist of obtaining passive income or of acting as an intermediary in trade in goods from or to Argentina or with other members of the group of economically related entities, Its international trade transactions with other members of the group of enterprises may not exceed 30% of the total volume of its annual transactions. In summary, the transfer pricing methodology set out in Article 15 of the Income Tax Law does not establish an order of priority and does not indicate any preferences as to the application of the methods other than those concerning international brokers (Article 15.6). However, the taxpayer must state the reasons why it selected and applied a given method to a given transaction.

Transfer pricing documentation requirements

With regard to the information required by the tax authorities from taxpayers in order to demonstrate that they acted in accordance with the arm's length principle, and the information that may additionally be required by the tax authorities under their audit powers, the following should be noted: No specific type of documentation has been defined. This is self-evident given that different economic situations arise in practice and it is therefore not possible to standardise the items required in such documentation. On the other hand, this allows taxpayers to use any documents, provided that they support and substantiate their arguments with respect to each of the elements required by the tax law provisions on transfer pricing and fit the situation concerned. The required documentation is not limited to the list of documents, because under certain conditions and in certain situations the documents on the list may prove insufficient or inapplicable to the pricing method in international transactions. For this reason, the list of documents was drawn up with the intention of serving as a guide for taxpayers preparing their documents. The documentation should not only be contemporaneous with the transaction but should also be prepared by the due date for filing the tax return. From that moment, the documentation should be available to the auditors and retained until the expiry of the limitation period for any claims to which it might give rise. To be accepted for evidentiary purposes, the documentation must meet all formal and current requirements, such as the use of the Spanish language or the translation of individual source documents by a certified translator. To this end, the data which the taxpayer should include in the documentation and which the tax authorities need in order to carry out a review or to apply one of the transfer pricing methods are as follows: Data and information on the taxpayer concerning the functions it performs and the activities it undertakes (e.g. production, research and development, marketing, sales and distribution, shipping, inventory holding, installation, after-sales service, administration, accounting, legal services, human resources, IT, financial management), Complete information on the foreign related party and documentation, if any, indicating the nature of the transaction under review. This is important because documentation concerning foreign related parties should exist even if no transaction with such a party takes place. This also means that in such a case it will not be necessary to comply with the transfer pricing information requirements, although the taxpayer will be obliged to document its relationships with related parties. Such information should be available for examination by the tax authorities. In the case of multinational enterprises, documentation is required showing: the activities carried on by each of the entities forming part of the enterprise, the transactions carried out between them, and other aspects. It must be borne in mind that the provision of information and supporting documentation concerns all members of the group, even those with which no transactions have been carried out. In addition, the following information is required: a description of the transactions carried out with related parties, their amount and the currency used, the consolidated financial statements, where relevant to the transfer pricing issue, the contracts and agreements performed by the parties to the transaction, information on the taxpayer's financial position, the competitive environment and the market in which it operates, its commercial strategy and cost structure. Information and documents supporting the transfer pricing procedure applied.

Specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific transfer pricing penalties

Argentine legislation has not introduced any special procedures for examining and verifying transfer prices. However, in connection with the existing penalties for transfer pricing manipulation and with regard to the existing documentation obligation, the tax procedure rules contain several provisions that may be applied in this sense. Thus, it was only upon the entry into force of Law No. 25.795 (which was published in the Official Gazette on 17 November 2003 and which amended the tax procedure rules) that Argentine legislation gained specific provisions on penalties imposed for non-compliance with the rules on international transactions, and these were added on the basis of the practical experience of the national tax authorities. The penalty regime in this respect is as follows: Automatic penalty – imposed without prior notice for failure to file a tax return by the prescribed deadline: With respect to supplementary information returns concerning export and import transactions carried out by independent enterprises, the penalties amount to: 1,500 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 316) for individuals and 9,000 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 1,895) for corporations. With respect to supplementary information returns concerning transactions carried out with foreign entities, the penalties amount to (in addition to the above): 10,000 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 2,105) for individuals and 20,000 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 4,210) for corporations. Penalty for non-compliance with provisions establishing or requiring the fulfilment of formal obligations relating to the assessment of tax liabilities and to the verification and examination of taxpayers' compliance with them. The penalties range from 150 (approx. USD 32) to 2,500 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 526). In the following cases, the penalties may be higher and range from 150 (approx. USD 32) to 45,000 (approx. USD 9,474) Argentine pesos: a) Resistance to an audit (repeated failure to respond to requests made by the tax authorities), b) Failure to keep documents evidencing the prices used in international transactions, c) Failure to provide data and information required for the purposes of auditing international transactions. Failure to file information returns concerning international transactions and returns containing information about the taxpayer itself or about third parties at the request of the tax authority. A penalty of between 500 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 105) and 45,000 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 9,474). This penalty is additional to those described above, and its amount depends on the taxpayer's status and the seriousness of the infringement committed. Higher-income taxpayers: Where the taxpayer's annual income amounts to 10,000,000 Argentine pesos (approx. USD 2,105,263) or more, the penalty imposed for non-compliance with the preceding point ranges from two to ten times the maximum penalty amount (45,000 Argentine pesos or approx. USD 9,474) and is added to the penalty calculated in the standard manner. Failure to pay tax In general: from 50% to 100% of the tax unpaid, withheld or collected, International transactions: from one to four times the tax unpaid or withheld.

Relevant provisions on transfer pricing agreements (advance pricing agreements)

In Argentina there are no legal provisions allowing taxpayers to enter into an advance pricing agreement.

Links to relevant government websites

Ministry of Economy and Public Finance: www.mecon.gov.ar Federal Administration of Public Revenue: www.afip.gov.ar

Other relevant information

1. Provisions of domestic law referring to the arm's length principle. 2. References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations in domestic law. 3. Domestic legislation or regulations containing a definition of related parties or associated enterprises. 4. Relevant legal provisions or regulations containing guidance on transfer pricing methods, including the order in which they are to be applied, if any. 5. Domestic provisions, if any, relating to transfer pricing documentation requirements. 6. Domestic provisions, if any, concerning specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific penalties in respect of transfer pricing. 7. Domestic provisions, if any, on advance pricing agreements. 8. Website addresses of the competent authorities responsible for transfer pricing policy and its administration and for advance pricing agreements. 9. Other relevant information, for example data from substantive reviews or transfer pricing provisions currently in preparation.

Prepared on the basis of the following material, status as at 22 November 2012, own translation: Anna Jarecka.