Australia
Reference to the arm's length principle
Division 13 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 – International Agreements and Determination of Source of Certain Income. Section 136AD: consideration due and accrued corresponding to arm's length prices. 136Ab(1) [Disposal of property: consideration below the arm's length price] Where: a taxpayer supplies goods under an international agreement, the Commissioner of Taxation, having regard to any connection between two or more of the parties to that agreement and to any other relevant circumstances, is satisfied that the parties to the agreement (two or more of them) are not observing the arm's length principle in carrying out the transaction, consideration has been received by the taxpayer or is due to the taxpayer in respect of the supply but is lower than would follow from the arm's length price of the goods supplied, the Commissioner of Taxation determines that this subsection should apply to the taxpayer in relation to the supplies, then, for the purposes of the application of this Act to the taxpayer, consideration equal to the consideration resulting from the arm's length principle shall be deemed to be the consideration due to or received by the taxpayer in respect of the supply of the property. 136 AD(2) [Disposal of property: no consideration] Where: a taxpayer supplies goods under an international agreement, the Commissioner of Taxation, having regard to any connection between two or more of the parties to that agreement and to any other relevant circumstances, is satisfied that the parties to the agreement (two or more of them) are not observing the arm's length principle in carrying out the transaction, the taxpayer has not received, and is not due, any consideration in respect of the supply, the Commissioner of Taxation determines that this subsection should apply to the taxpayer in relation to the supplies, then, for the purposes of the application of this Act to the taxpayer, consideration equal to the consideration resulting from the arm's length principle shall be deemed to be the consideration received by or due to the taxpayer in respect of the supply of the property at the time when it was supplied or, if the situation so requires, at the time when the first part of the property was supplied, or at such later time or times as the Commissioner of Taxation may decide. 136AB(3) [Acquisition of property: excessive payment] Where: a taxpayer supplies goods under an international agreement, the Commissioner of Taxation, having regard to any connection between two or more of the parties to that agreement and to any other relevant circumstances, is satisfied that the parties to the agreement (two or more of them) are not observing the arm's length principle in carrying out the transaction, the taxpayer has paid or has undertaken to pay, for the acquisition of the property, a price that is excessive in relation to the arm's length price of the property acquired, the Commissioner of Taxation determines that this subsection should apply to the taxpayer in relation to the acquisition, then, for the purposes of the application of this Act to the taxpayer, consideration equal to the consideration resulting from the arm's length principle shall be deemed to be the consideration paid or to be paid by the taxpayer for the property acquired. 136AD(4) [Payment of the arm's length price: estimate made by the Commissioner of Taxation] For the purposes of this section, if any reason (including a lack of access to the necessary information) prevents the Commissioner of Taxation from ascertaining whether the arm's length principle was applied in determining the consideration for the supply or acquisition of property, the amount indicated by the Commissioner of Taxation shall be deemed to be the actual amount of that consideration.
References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines
References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines are contained in the following Taxation Rulings: Taxation Ruling TR 94/14 (general concept) Taxation Ruling TR 97/20 (methodology for determining arm's length prices) Taxation Ruling TR 98/11 (documentation) Taxation Ruling TR 1999/1 (intra-group services) Taxation Ruling TR 2004/1 (cost contribution arrangements)
Definition of related parties
None. Division 13 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 applies to international transactions in which the prices do not satisfy the arm's length principle, even if such transactions are carried out by unrelated parties.
Transfer pricing methods
Taxation Ruling TR 97/20 distinguishes 5 acceptable, standard methods for determining transfer prices: traditional methods: the comparable uncontrolled price method, the resale price method and the cost plus method, transactional profit methods: the profit split method, the transactional net margin method. Taxation Ruling TR 97/20 does not introduce any hierarchy or order of application of the above methods; in each case, the method to be applied should be the one that is most appropriate for objectively determining the arm's length price in the given circumstances of the transaction and in relation to the data available.
Transfer pricing documentation requirements
Taxation Ruling TR 98/11 specifies what should be contained in the documentation compiled by the taxpayer in order to demonstrate the efforts it has made to comply with the arm's length principle. As a general rule, the documentation should be evidence that the taxpayer has followed the following 4 steps in setting and reviewing transfer prices: Step 1: Preparing a characterisation of the international transaction between related parties in the context of the taxpayer's business and attaching the relevant documents to it, Step 2: Selecting the most appropriate transfer pricing method (for the given transaction) and attaching documents justifying that choice, Step 3: Applying the selected transfer pricing method, determining the income resulting from the arm's length principle and gathering the documents relating to those processes, Step 4: Implementing support processes. Carrying out a review enabling adjustments to be made and documenting that process. Documentation is regarded as contemporaneous if it is created at the time when the taxpayer is developing or implementing any arrangements that may involve a transfer pricing issue, or when it reviews such arrangements prior to or at the time of preparing its tax return.
Specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific transfer pricing penalties
Audit procedures Taxation Ruling TR 98/11 lays down the rules on the basis of which the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) examines whether transfer prices comply with the arm's length principle. In short, this process has the same 4 steps as apply where the taxpayer prepares transfer pricing documentation meeting the administrative requirements. Before deciding to commence a transfer pricing audit procedure, the ATO carries out a preliminary transfer pricing review, in which the following are taken into account: the quality of the processes implemented by the taxpayer, the content of the relevant and adequate documents provided by the taxpayer, whether the outcome of the international transaction with the related enterprise provides the taxpayer with an arm's length result. Penalties In short, section 225 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 and Division 284 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 provide for the following penalties applicable to transfer pricing adjustments: 50% of the tax avoided as a result of transfer pricing arrangements entered into with the sole or the dominant entity in order to enable less tax to be paid or no tax to be paid at all; a reduction of the penalty rate to 25% is possible if the taxpayer adopts a different position and is able to justify it logically, 25% of the tax avoided through other transfer pricing arrangements; a reduction of the penalty rate to 10% is possible if the taxpayer adopts a different position and is able to justify it logically. The Commissioner has discretion to remit all or part of the penalty. Taxation Rulings TR 98/11 and TR 98/16 ensure that a taxpayer who has, in good faith, followed the 4 steps of the process in preparing its tax return and has gathered sufficient and relevant documentation demonstrating that its transfer prices comply with the arm's length principle will not be charged the above penalties.
Relevant provisions on transfer pricing agreements (advance pricing agreements)
Taxation Ruling TR 95/23 contains guidance on APAs and a description of the process for implementing them. The ATO has also published a short guide explaining the Australian advance pricing agreement programme. Any taxpayer that carries out international transactions with a related party, concludes contracts and arrangements with such a party or has common interests with it may apply for an APA. However, the ATO has reserved the right to refuse to accept an application for an advance pricing agreement if, for example, the transactions that would be covered by such an agreement will not materialise or are merely hypothetical, or if the pricing methodology proposed in the application is not consistent with Australian law and is unlikely to ensure results consistent with the arm's length principle. Australia encourages the conclusion of bilateral pricing agreements wherever this is possible in the given situation. From a formal point of view, an APA application must contain information on the proposed conditions that may affect the application of the transfer pricing methodology. However, there is no form on which the application is to be made, and no fees are charged for filing it. A taxpayer considering applying for an APA should contact the competent tax authority in order to arrange an exploratory (preliminary) meeting.
Links to relevant government websites
Australian Taxation Office
Other relevant information
1. Provisions of domestic law referring to the arm's length principle. 2. References to the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations in domestic law. 3. Domestic legislation or regulations containing a definition of related parties or associated enterprises. 4. Relevant legislation or regulations containing guidance on transfer pricing methods, including the order in which they are to be applied, if any. 5. Domestic provisions, if any, relating to transfer pricing documentation requirements. 6. Domestic provisions, if any, concerning specific transfer pricing audit procedures or specific penalties relating to transfer pricing. 7. Domestic provisions, if any, on advance pricing agreements. 8. Website addresses of the competent authorities responsible for transfer pricing policy and its administration and for advance pricing agreements. 9. Other relevant information, for example data from substantive reviews or transfer pricing provisions currently in preparation.
Prepared on the basis of the following material; status as at November 2006; own translation by Anna Jarecka.
