Transfer pricing: frequently asked questions
Transfer pricing restrictions, as a tool for safeguarding the tax revenues flowing into state budgets, are still a fairly new solution. The provisions on transfer pricing are highly complicated, which is why applying them causes companies many problems. The authorities empowered to carry out audits are not always able to cope with the complex issue of transfer pricing either, which may lead to conflict between the tax administration and taxpayers. To shed some light on the problematic issues, we are publishing a list of the questions most frequently asked in the context of transfer pricing.
What are transfer prices?
Transfer prices are the financial results of conditions agreed or imposed that apply in transactions between related parties. They may be prices in the sense of the price for goods sold, services, or intangible assets, but also remuneration, financial results or financial ratios. In Poland, the detailed legal provisions on transfer pricing are laid down in two acts: the Corporate Income Tax Act (CIT) and the Personal Income Tax Act (PIT).
Which entities are related?
Related parties are entities between which significant relationships exist. These entities may be legal persons, natural persons and also organisational units without legal personality that participate in the management of another entity or exercise control over it. They are often companies belonging to a single group of companies. The relationship between entities may be of various kinds: capital (e.g. where one of the companies holds at least 25% of the shares in the other), personal (e.g. where the same persons sit on the management boards of two companies), but also informal (where there is no official relationship, but it is obvious or highly probable that one entity has a real influence on the activity of the other).
What is the purpose of transfer pricing?
Transfer pricing has numerous functions, both in the context of the economy and of the individual company. Above all, its proper application minimises the risk arising from carrying out transactions between related parties. This makes it possible to plan and coordinate activities across all the related parties within the group. From the state’s perspective, transfer pricing prevents actions that are not in the state’s interest (i.e. reducing the amount of tax by shifting profits and costs between entities), and it also safeguards fair competition and the application of market conditions.
Who creates the legal regulations on transfer pricing?
Transfer pricing provisions can be broadly divided into regulations and recommendations. Regulations have the force of law. As transfer pricing concerns international operations, it is international governmental organisations that perform the regulatory function in this case. These organisations include the UN, the OECD and the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum. Given the enormous importance of transfer pricing in the context of the market economy and the fairness of the transactions concluded, non-governmental organisations are able to formulate recommendations (which may, but need not, be reflected in legal regulations). In Poland, this subject is dealt with primarily by the Transfer Pricing Centre Association.
How are transfer prices determined?
The methods for determining transfer prices have been listed by the OECD in the form of recommendations, but this catalogue is not a closed one. In practice, entities do indeed most often choose one of the 5 proposed methods. This is because choosing a method of one’s own requires an explanation of why none of the 5 OECD proposals is suitable for use in the specific situation and why the method proposed by the taxpayer is better. The methods proposed by the OECD are the comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method, the resale price method, the cost plus method, the transactional net margin method (TNMM) and the profit split method.
What does transfer pricing documentation contain?
Transfer pricing documentation is evidence that transfer prices have been determined correctly. It must be made available to the tax authorities at their request. That is why preparing it meticulously is so important. Transfer pricing documentation contains basic information about the entities and about the transaction, including the cost of the transaction, the form and date of payment, a description of the entity’s business strategy, the method of calculating the expected profits/benefits, and any other information that is relevant in the context of the given transaction.
Must transfer prices be documented for every transaction with a related party?
Not all transactions between related parties require transfer pricing documentation to be prepared. The legislator has provided for thresholds linked to the value of the transaction. They differ for different types of transaction. At present these thresholds are PLN 10 million for a goods transaction and a financial transaction and PLN 2 million for a service transaction or other transaction. The thresholds are additionally reduced if the entity enters into a transaction with a company registered in a so-called tax haven.
Who checks that transfer pricing is applied correctly, and how?
Verification of the correct application of transfer pricing may be the subject of an audit by the tax authorities empowered to carry it out. They initiate an administrative and fiscal procedure in the course of which the transactions concluded with related parties are scrutinised in detail. For the most part these audits are of a cross-check nature – that is, they take place simultaneously in all the entities involved in the transaction.
What are tax havens?
Tax haven is the colloquial name for countries and dependent territories that engage in harmful tax competition. The harm lies in the fact that, in order to attract investors and their capital, these states offer very lenient tax conditions (including low tax rates and numerous exemptions from paying tax). Some companies decide to carry out transactions with entities from tax havens precisely because of the very favourable tax conditions, and not because of the specific nature and uniqueness of the products or services. The Ministry of Finance publishes a list of tax havens, which currently contains 26 countries and dependent territories. This is important because the transaction thresholds for the application of transfer pricing are considerably lower in the case of transactions with entities from tax havens.
What is a safe harbour?
Safe harbour is a mechanism of simplified rules for preparing transfer pricing documentation. It may be used by related parties if the transaction concerns a low-value service or a loan. In this case the tax authority refrains from determining income or loss as regards the level of the mark-up on the costs of the service or the level of interest on the loan. This means that the entities do not have to prepare transfer pricing documentation for transactions that meet these criteria.
How can one move efficiently in the area of transfer pricing?
Complying with the provisions on transfer pricing can be very complicated. It is therefore worth making use of the solutions offered by specialist firms, such as a transfer pricing audit or transfer pricing training for the management board or the finance function. It is very helpful to draw up a coherent internal transfer pricing policy, constituting a set of procedures to be followed in the course of transactions with related parties.
The above overview does not, of course, exhaust the complex subject of transfer pricing; it merely signals certain issues connected with it. In practice the matter is so complicated that even people with the relevant education, as well as extensive knowledge and experience in the field of finance and international transactions, are not always able to cope with carrying out individual transactions correctly and then reporting them. Meanwhile, the penalties that entrepreneurs may face are very severe. It is not worth counting on luck or being guided by business intuition, which in this case may not be the best adviser. A far better solution is to use the support of a professional firm specialising in transfer pricing.
