Tax havens and transfer pricing: what you need to know
Transfer pricing regulations are a solution introduced on an international scale, intended to protect state budgets against the leakage of tax revenue due from companies that carry out transactions with related parties located in the territories of different states. Consequently, the obligation to apply transfer pricing rests primarily on taxpayers who, occasionally or regularly, conduct transactions with companies to which they are linked by capital or personal ties. There is, however, a special category of entities for which the transfer pricing restrictions apply even where the companies are not related to one another. These are enterprises located in the territory of so-called tax havens. What characterises these countries? Why are they so attractive from a tax perspective? Do all transactions with them require the application of transfer pricing? What obligations do taxpayers have when they decide to enter into business relationships with companies from tax havens?
What are tax havens?
Tax havens, also known as tax oases, are states, administrative areas of states or dependent territories characterised by exceptionally lenient tax rules – not, however, for their own residents (or not only for them), but above all for foreign entities. The purpose of designing such rules is to attract foreign capital. Tax havens entice entrepreneurs, who can avoid high taxes in their home countries by transferring profits to states that are tax havens. For this reason, the official name for tax havens is countries applying harmful tax competition.
The mechanism of using tax havens to reduce taxes is complicated, but many companies consider it worth the effort. It involves generating fictitious business costs. Companies set up branches or related companies in the territory of a tax haven, to which they then transfer profits. A popular way of generating costs is, for example, the sale of licences, copyrights or graphic marks for enormous sums. Another frequent practice is the sale of semi-finished products or products at very low prices to entities in a tax haven, which in turn resell them, now with an appropriate margin, while paying considerably less tax than would have to be paid in a country that is not a tax haven. It is estimated that more than 32 trillion dollars are hidden in tax havens in this way.
Transfer pricing rules are intended to curb such practices and to ensure that transactions with tax havens are no more profitable than those carried out locally.
The Ministry of Finance list in force since 2020 contains 37 countries and dependent territories regarded as tax havens. Most of them are islands in the Caribbean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean, situated in North America, as well as islands in the Pacific, in Oceania. At the same time, the most popular tax havens can be found within a radius of 3 000 km of Warsaw (e.g. Andorra, Monaco, Liechtenstein). Transactions concluded with Hong Kong are also very popular among Polish entrepreneurs. Interestingly, not a single tax haven is located in South America.
Which transactions with tax havens require the application of transfer pricing?
In order to eliminate various forms of tax evasion, transfer pricing obligations apply not only to related parties located in the territories of tax havens, but to all companies that have their registered office there. As in the case of related parties located in countries that are not tax havens, documentation thresholds also apply to tax haven transactions, below which transfer pricing does not apply.
For financial transactions with entities from tax havens, the documentation threshold is 2 500 00 PLN. For all other transactions the threshold is considerably lower – as little as 500 000 PLN is enough to make it necessary to document the application of transfer pricing.
Exceeding the stated limits in a given tax year means that the taxpayer must prepare a local file, justify the transaction, together with the conditions under which it took place, in terms of its arm's length nature, and also submit the TPR form and the relevant statement.
What obligations does a taxpayer carrying out tax haven transactions have?
The first of the above-mentioned obligations arising from transactions with entities located in tax havens is therefore the documentation obligation. The local file for transactions with companies from tax havens does not differ from the same type of documentation for transactions with related parties in standard circumstances – with one exception. Instead of a transfer pricing analysis, an economic justification of the transaction must be prepared. In addition, the documentation must contain a description of the entity, a description of the transaction itself (including the assets and risks), and financial information about the company.
The economic justification of the transaction must include a reliable presentation of the expected benefits – both economic and tax-related. Naturally, both the entity carrying out the transaction and the authority entitled to conduct audits are aware of what kind of tax benefits may result from tax haven transactions. These may be, for example, the complete absence of tax or a significant reduction in it, the deferral of its payment date, or even quite the opposite – the creation or overstatement of a tax loss, together with an overpayment and a right to a tax refund, or the overstatement thereof.
In turn, the economic benefits most often derived from doing business with entities from tax havens include, above all, an increase in profitability and market share, greater labour productivity and competitive advantage, and even increased brand recognition. These benefits in themselves are of course in no way improper or undesirable – the point, however, is that they should not be achieved at the expense of the state.
Providing an economic justification for a transaction with an entity located in a tax haven may prove to be a very complicated undertaking. It should be borne in mind that the justification must provide fairly detailed information in order to explain why the transaction was concluded with that particular entity. Companies from tax havens are reluctant to share any data and are generally not willing to cooperate with tax authorities. Meanwhile, an unreliable and incomplete economic justification may result in the legitimacy of the transaction being challenged and tax proceedings being initiated, and even in penalties being imposed.
The last of the obligations of a company doing business with tax haven entities is the requirement to submit the TPR form together with the statement. The form is intended to give the auditing authorities knowledge of the subject of the transaction, its value and the country in which the counterparty's registered office is located.
Why do transactions with tax havens cause so many problems?
It might seem that the legislator is going somewhat too far here – does the very fact that a transaction was concluded with an unrelated party not attest to its arm's length nature? In the case of tax havens, the audit authorities are guided by justified suspicion. Because of the very liberal tax rules in tax havens, these countries encourage entrepreneurs to act dishonestly.
This does not mean that every transaction with a tax haven will be challenged. Entrepreneurs who make use of this possibility must nevertheless reckon with the fact that an audit awaits them.
It is not without reason that the states and territories classed as tax havens pursue precisely this kind of tax policy. Their aim is to attract companies that may be tempted by exceptionally low levies. A ban on such transactions would be a breach of market principles. That is why states that require their taxpayers to apply transfer pricing most often extend this obligation to tax havens as well – as a result, business cooperation with entities located there is possible and, at the same time, does not cause losses to the budget of the state that is not a tax haven.
