Transfer pricing: the most common doubts
The institution of transfer pricing does not always meet with understanding on the part of entrepreneurs. First, since transfer pricing rules came into force in Poland and in the EU, tax optimisation by shifting costs between companies within a capital group has become considerably more difficult. Second, transfer pricing is a complex subject requiring extensive knowledge of international law, finance and accounting, and often also of trade or management. Finding a specialist who is fully at ease in the field of transfer pricing is therefore no easy task. See which doubts are raised most often by the people responsible for applying the transfer pricing mechanism in companies.
Are transfer prices taxes?
No – although thinking so is not unjustified. After all, the provisions relating to transfer pricing are contained in the PIT Act and the CIT Act. They are, however, not so much taxes as a mechanism intended to secure tax revenue at the appropriate level. In other words, transfer prices are the financial results of conditions agreed or imposed in transactions taking place between related parties. They may therefore be not only prices as such (in the sense of the price of a good, a service or an intangible asset), but also, among other things, financial indicators, financial results or remuneration. Transfer pricing regulations are international in nature – and thus apply in all EU and OECD countries.
Do only official links between entities count?
No. The links between entities that give rise to the obligation to set transfer prices may also be unofficial. But first things first: the obligation to apply transfer pricing rests primarily (though not exclusively) on related parties that enter into transactions with one another. These links may be of various kinds. Most often we speak of capital links (e.g. where one company holds at least a 25% share in the profits of another company) or personal links (e.g. where the composition of the management board or supervisory board of two companies overlaps). However, the institutions responsible for monitoring the application of transfer pricing may also identify links that are unofficial but significant enough for the transfer pricing restrictions to be required. This may happen, for example, where a company formally has one president, but in reality decisions are taken by another person who is officially the president of the other company.
Why does the state make life difficult for entrepreneurs by forcing them to apply transfer pricing?
The point is not at all to make life difficult for entrepreneurs, but to secure state budget revenue from the taxes paid by companies operating within a capital group and by other entities carrying out international (and not only international) transactions. Transfer pricing also has an economic dimension – it guarantees the application of arm's length conditions in transactions between entities, which in turn helps to preserve fair competition. For the company itself, meanwhile, transfer pricing documentation is proof that its transactions are carried out in accordance with the law.
Which bodies are responsible for creating transfer pricing regulations?
This is done primarily by international governmental organisations – the issue of transfer pricing is a serious one and is supranational in nature. The regulatory function in the field of transfer pricing is therefore performed by, among others, the UN, the OECD and the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum. In addition, a voice is given to non-governmental organisations whose mission is to ensure fair conditions for market participants. It should be noted, however, that NGOs may express their views only in the form of recommendations. Whether these will be implemented in international law is not certain. In Poland, the best-known non-governmental organisation dealing with transfer pricing is the Transfer Pricing Centre Association.
Can you propose your own method of setting transfer prices?
Yes, but there is a catch: you must prove that the 5 methods proposed by the OECD will not work in the given situation and demonstrate the superiority (in particular the greater appropriateness) of your own method. Of course, the fact that this method makes it possible to save on taxes will not be a sufficient argument for the audit authorities. Most often, therefore, entities choose one of the OECD methods (the comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method, the resale price method, the cost plus method, the transactional net margin method (TNMM), the profit split method).
How detailed must transfer pricing documentation be?
Fairly detailed. In fact, this is primarily in the interest of the company rather than of the authorities empowered to carry out audits. Scrupulously providing the maximum amount of information will place the taxpayer beyond all doubt. Transfer pricing documentation must therefore contain information about the entities taking part in the transaction as well as about the transaction itself (e.g. its cost, the agreed payment date and form of payment, and the way in which the expected profits or benefits were calculated). Besides the mandatory data, the taxpayer should also include in the documentation anything else that seems relevant to them in the context of the transaction concerned.
Does transfer pricing documentation have to be prepared for all transactions with related parties?
No. This is one of the few concessions to taxpayers – value thresholds apply to transactions with related parties. They differ for individual transactions – for a goods transaction and a financial transaction the threshold is PLN 10 million, and for a service transaction or other transaction – PLN 2 million. In addition, in the case of a low value-adding service or a loan, entities may make use of the safe harbour mechanism, which means that documentation need not be prepared for these types of transaction.
Can any transactions other than those with related parties also require the application of transfer pricing?
Yes – there are quite a few transactions for which transfer pricing is required even though no related parties take part in the transaction. Transfer pricing is required, among other cases, for transactions between unrelated parties where there is a suspicion that the prices were agreed (or indeed imposed) as a result of indirect links (e.g. as a result of group negotiations). In the case of transactions with tax havens, too, the obligation to set transfer prices must be reckoned with – the thresholds for individual transactions will in this case be considerably lower than for related parties! In addition, transfer pricing is required for reorganisations within a capital group if they result in a significant change in financial or commercial relations, or a transfer of functions, assets or risks between entities. Transfer pricing may be required even in the case of transactions with natural persons if they have an influence on the functioning of the company (e.g. a transaction between a company and a member of its management board). The obligation to apply transfer pricing also covers some gratuitous benefits (e.g. the granting of a licence, a guarantee or a surety).
Although transfer pricing is part of everyday life for companies carrying out transactions with related parties, applying it correctly can cause many problems. The complexity of the rules means that mistakes are easily made. Unfortunately, the institutions empowered to carry out an audit are unlikely to inquire into whether the failure to fulfil one or another transfer pricing duty was deliberate or the result of ignorance. The penalties can be very severe – ranging from financial consequences, through tax consequences, to criminal ones (in relation to members of the management board or supervisory board, chief accountants or finance directors). If the application of transfer pricing raises any doubts in your company, do not count on luck – use the support of a professional entity that deals with transfer pricing for a living. Such a firm can carry out an audit and training, help to develop a coherent transfer pricing policy and procedures, and also take over the obligation to apply transfer pricing – depending on the agreed scope of cooperation.
