Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Types of transaction subject to transfer pricing obligations: what you need to know

Types of transaction subject to transfer pricing obligations: what you need to know

Published:

Transfer pricing regulations are a means of safeguarding the interests of the state by preventing tax optimisation that is not permitted by law. Their application is commonly associated with related parties – and indeed, most transactions that require the transfer pricing guidelines to be applied are of precisely that nature. Which transactions exactly are concerned, and when else does transfer pricing call for caution?

Transactions with parties related by capital

Related parties are those between which a significant dependence exists. That dependence may take various forms, but most often it is a capital dependence. A capital dependence can be said to exist where one entity holds at least 25% of the capital of another entity. In such a situation the legislator imposes a number of obligations connected with the application of transfer pricing, in order to minimise the risk of the entities concerned engaging in impermissible tax optimisation. The transaction thresholds differ in amount for the individual types of transaction.

Transactions with parties related by personal ties

Entities related by personal ties often decide to cooperate. In this case, significant influence is deemed to exist where one entity holds at least 25% of the voting rights in the decision-making, management or supervisory bodies of another entity. Situations in which one natural person combines functions in the above-mentioned bodies of several entities are also common. As in the case of a capital relationship, here too there is a risk of costs being shifted between companies in order to reduce tax liabilities artificially.

Transactions with informally related parties

An interesting group of transactions subject to transfer pricing restrictions consists of those concluded between entities that are not formally related, but between which there is nevertheless an informal dependence strong enough to have a material effect on the terms agreed for the transaction. Examples here are family ties or friendships between persons sitting on the decision-making, management or supervisory bodies of different companies. Relationships of this kind can be difficult to prove, but where they do exist, transactions between the entities will likewise be subjected to more detailed scrutiny.

Goods transactions with related parties

Related parties may carry out transactions of various kinds. Among the most frequently encountered are goods transactions, that is, transactions in which goods are sold by one entity to another. If a material dependence exists between the entities (for example, they are companies operating within a single capital group), particular care must be taken to demonstrate that arm's length conditions were observed when the transfer prices were set, without artificially understating or overstating the value of the goods sold and purchased. For goods transactions between related parties, the documentation threshold is PLN 10 million.

Service transactions with related parties

The audit authorities analyse service transactions between related parties with particular thoroughness. The reason for this is simple: it is in the pricing of services that impermissible financial optimisation occurs most easily, as a result of their value being overstated or understated. This applies to services of any type: accounting, legal, consulting, IT, engineering, warehousing, transport and so on. Related parties between which service transactions take place must therefore prepare a reliable price analysis that reflects reality, in order to set the price of the services at arm's length level and avoid problems with the tax authorities. In the case of service transactions the threshold is considerably lower – it amounts to PLN 2 million, that is, 1/5 of the value of goods transactions covered by the obligation to apply transfer pricing.

Financial transactions with related parties

Apart from buying and selling goods and services, related parties may also carry out financial transactions. This primarily concerns the granting of loans and credit between entities in a capital group. The area in which the tax authorities may identify irregularities is the interest rate. Like the prices of goods and services, it should be set on arm's length terms, reflecting the interest rate that would have been adopted for identical or similar transactions had they taken place between unrelated parties. The documentation threshold for these transactions is PLN 10 million, the same as for goods transactions.

Intangible and legal transactions with related parties

Not all transactions taking place between related parties are of a tangible nature. That does not mean, however, that the tax authorities will take no interest in them. Intangible transactions, that is, financial and business operations, also belong to the group of controlled transactions. This may be, for example, a transfer of intangible assets or the conclusion of an agreement on joint risk management. The gratuitous benefits covered by the obligation to document transfer prices also include the granting of guarantees and sureties, as well as licences for the use of assets – both proprietary and personal. Intangible transactions between related parties must likewise reflect arm's length conditions. The materiality threshold for them is PLN 2 million, and is therefore identical to that for service transactions.

Restructuring and capital transactions

Restructuring is always a process that attracts the particular attention of the audit authorities. If restructuring proceedings are to result in a material change in the financial or commercial relations between related parties, and likewise where assets or risks are transferred between those parties, transfer pricing documentation must be prepared. This obligation arises where, as a result of the reorganisation, the change in EBIT amounts to at least 20%. Events such as acquisitions, mergers or demergers of companies, transfers of shares, capital increases, the conversion of debt into equity, and the making of cash contributions and contributions in kind will come under the eye of the tax authorities.

Transactions with unrelated parties in which related parties were indirectly involved

Although transfer pricing is associated mainly with related parties, there are cases in which unrelated parties must also be mindful of it. This primarily concerns the situation in which the terms of a transaction are agreed, or indeed imposed, for example in the course of group negotiations. The central entity may then take part in setting the terms of a transaction between one of the entities in its capital group and an independent entity. The transaction taking place between them will thus ostensibly concern two independent entities, but the interest of the central entity means that controlled transfer prices must be applied in order to ensure arm's length terms for the transaction.

Transactions with entities established in tax havens

In their search for tax optimisation, many companies turn towards geographical areas characterised by an exceptionally liberal tax policy, especially for companies with foreign capital. Such countries and dependent territories are called tax havens. Entering into business relations with entities that have their registered offices there is not illegal, but it is subject to very thorough scrutiny. Transfer pricing documentation must be prepared where the annual value of transactions with a tax-haven entity amounts to at least PLN 2.5 million for financial transactions or PLN 0.5 million for non-financial transactions.

Transactions with certain natural persons

Even certain transactions with natural persons require transfer prices to be documented. This applies where an entity carries out a transaction with, for example, the president of its own management board or its commercial proxy, and thus with a person who has a direct influence on the functioning of the enterprise.

Transfer pricing is a complicated matter and frequently causes many problems, not only for accountants and finance directors. Since the consequences of errors in this area can be very costly, it is worth drawing on the support of a professional firm offering, among other things, audits, training and the preparation of internal procedures and policies.

Related articles