Resolving transfer pricing disputes
Various types of transactions may take place between related parties (related through capital, e.g. where one entity holds shares in another, or through persons, e.g. through individuals sitting on the management boards of both companies). This is justified both logically and logistically. In order to safeguard the interests of the state – i.e. budget revenue from the taxes paid – a tool was created in the form of transfer pricing obligations. Transfer prices are the terms of transactions concluded between related parties. The amount of tax paid by taxpayers depends on the criteria adopted for setting transfer prices. However, if their registered offices are located in different countries, interpreting the regulations in force in the individual countries may be complicated.
The subject of the dispute – double taxation
The operation of related parties within a group structure means that transactions will often take place between Polish and foreign companies. The very delimitation of the income earned by these international enterprises, from the perspective of the tax jurisdictions of the individual states, is already problematic. The phenomenon of income shifting occurs – it is natural that entities will seek to optimise their financial results, including through legally permitted manipulation at the tax level (e.g. preferring to pay tax in the country where it is lower, or where the entities are entitled to specific exemptions). By contractually setting inflated or understated prices, entities can exploit differences in taxation between states.
States do not remain indifferent to such practices. Where the tax authority of a given country finds that the state it represents is at risk of a reduction in tax revenue, it may adjust the entity's income. The so-called primary adjustment is intended to eliminate the tax advantages resulting directly from the geographical location of the entities making up the capital group. The tax authorities will determine the income by way of estimation, using the methods permitted by local tax law. This, in turn, may lead to double taxation of the shifted portion of income – tax will be paid both by the taxpayer to whom the income has been attributed and by the entity related to it, as a result of comparable taxes being imposed on different taxpayers in different states. Such a situation is obviously disadvantageous from the point of view of all the entities and is bound to provoke objection. A dispute therefore arises between the taxpayer and the state. The subject of the conflict is unfair double taxation.
What is more, manipulating transfer prices may affect not only the entities' income tax but also VAT. In this situation, too, the tax authority will determine the amount of turnover constituting the taxable amount on the basis of the market value of the goods or services.
Ways of eliminating double taxation
If double taxation has arisen in a given entity as a result of a primary income adjustment applied by the tax authorities, there are mechanisms designed to avoid this unfavourable situation. The Model Convention of the OECD (the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development), which is the source of tax regulations in this area, provides for the possibility of making a corresponding income adjustment. If a state makes an adjustment under which an entity located in its territory is obliged to pay tax on profit on which tax has already been paid by another enterprise in another state, and the taxpayer demonstrates that the prices set between the entities were the same as they would have been between unrelated entities, the country in which the repeated, unjustified taxation occurred is obliged to change the amount of tax. For a corresponding adjustment to take effect, the state in whose territory the shifted income was disclosed must accept that the attribution of profit to the entity located in the territory of the other state, made by that other state, was justified both in principle and as regards the amount due.
It is worth noting here that the OECD cannot force a state to make an adjustment. The tax authorities of both states are obliged to endeavour to reach an agreement, but there are no provisions that would impose an obligation to reach a consensus.
Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP)
MAP is a procedure created to resolve disputes concerning potential double taxation, as well as to mitigate the effects of double taxation that has already occurred. In Poland its application is governed by the so-called DRM Act (Act of 16 October 2019 on the resolution of disputes concerning double taxation and the conclusion of advance pricing agreements, Journal of Laws of 2019, item 2200).
The procedure is initiated at the taxpayer's request. It is recommended to initiate it as soon as there is a suspicion that the actions taken by the tax authorities create a risk of double taxation. The request should be submitted simultaneously to the authorities of both states concerned. The entity bears no administrative fees for submitting the request.
Importantly, the taxpayer is not a party to the proceedings. The parties are the competent authorities for resolving double taxation disputes operating in the individual states. In Poland this is the Ministry of Finance. This does not mean, however, that the taxpayer has no say – the taxpayer will take part in establishing the circumstances of the situation under analysis.
The procedure may end with an agreement being concluded with the tax authorities of the other state. Only on that basis can proceedings be reopened with a view to determining anew, and correctly, the income or loss reported by the taxpayer.
A decision should not be expected quickly – the procedure takes around 3 years on average. The statistics are nevertheless optimistic – as many as 46% of the proceedings in which Poland has taken part have so far ended in the complete elimination of double taxation.
The arbitration mechanism
But what if the tax authorities of the states concerned fail to reach an agreement? Since tax has been paid in both countries, the only party that loses out in this situation is the taxpayer. Once again the OECD comes to the rescue. A taxpayer who feels aggrieved may request that the disputed issue be submitted to arbitration. The mutual agreement worked out through arbitration binds both states, provided that the applicant does not challenge the decision. Time limits under the tax regulations of the two countries are irrelevant in this case – their tax authorities must reach an agreement.
The arbitration procedure, which is an amicable procedure, requires the appointment of independent arbitrators (from outside the two states concerned). They examine the case in detail and are obliged to issue a ruling within 6 months of the date on which the request was submitted. That ruling is final and cannot be challenged either by the tax authorities of the states concerned or by the applicant – i.e. the taxpayer who claims that double taxation has occurred in its case in connection with the application of transfer pricing.
In addition, EU Member States are bound by the so-called Arbitration Convention (Convention 90/436/EEC). Under it, the tax authorities of the Member States are obliged to avoid double taxation. It is an effective mechanism, but for obvious reasons it can be enforced only with respect to taxpayers with their registered offices in the EU.
Tax regulations can be complicated enough at the national level. When the laws of different states have to be applied in the context of international operations, the level of difficulty increases many times over. A company risks making a costly mistake – acting unlawfully may end in the initiation of fiscal, financial or even criminal proceedings. That is why it is better to use the advice of a firm specialising in transfer pricing if transactions between related parties within a capital group occur regularly.
