Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Transfer pricing and tax risk management

Transfer pricing and tax risk management

Published:

TP, i.e. transfer pricing, applies to transactions taking place between related parties. The relationship may be based on capital or on personal ties, and both formal and informal links are taken into account. In addition, TP covers transactions with entities having their registered office in the territory of so-called tax havens – that is, countries engaging in harmful tax competition. Because the rules in this area are fairly complicated and often ambiguous, transactions between related parties may contribute to increased tax risk. Find out which mechanisms to apply in order to protect yourself against it.

Why does transfer pricing increase tax risk in related parties?

Tax risk is characteristic of business as such. It stems from the existence of certain sanctions for failing to fulfil tax obligations, fulfilling them improperly or missing deadlines. Sometimes such conduct on the part of an entrepreneur is deliberate, but more often it results from a misinterpretation of the regulations in force. The most important aspect of business risk is the lack of certainty as to whether any past, current or planned action will bring negative tax consequences.

In the case of transfer pricing, the problem is particularly acute. The regulations governing it are imprecise and change over time. For this reason, the tax authorities are not yet practised in examining transactions for their correctness. Court case law on which one could rely is also often lacking. All of this translates into increased tax risk for entities.

Transfer pricing documentation in the management of transfer pricing

From the state's perspective, the greatest risk relating to related parties is the possibility of shifting income between them in order to obtain financial benefits. It was for this very reason that it was decided that transfer pricing rules needed to be laid down in such a way that transfer prices correspond to market prices. In Poland, as in most countries of the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development), there is an obligation to prepare specific documentation whose purpose is to demonstrate that the transfer price is consistent with the market price.

Preparing the documentation correctly is the most important element in minimising tax risk in the case of related parties. It consists of several stages. First, the functions of the entities taking part in the transaction must be identified (by carrying out a functional analysis, an asset analysis and a risk analysis). Next, the costs of the transaction must be indicated, as well as the date and form of payment. It is very important to specify the method and manner of calculating profits, as well as the price of the subject matter of the transaction. Several recommended methods serve this purpose, although a method of one's own may also be applied if its choice is logically substantiated. Then the business strategy in force when the prices were being set (e.g. a promotion on launching a new brand on the market) must be presented, together with all other relevant factors. Finally, it is necessary to specify what benefits relating to intangible services the related parties obtained in connection with the transaction.

Methods of obtaining information on transfer prices

Managing tax risk in the case of transfer pricing requires the meticulous gathering of information on the transaction itself, the entities carrying it out, the market environment, the competition and so on. All circumstances that were known to the parties to the transaction at the time it was concluded, or that we at least assume could have been known to them, must be borne in mind.

Information can be obtained from various sources. The basic one is an analysis of source documents – that is, above all, the transaction agreement. It is always worth drawing on expert knowledge by using the business intelligence services of specialised entities. The tax authority will also admit evidence from direct interviews with the persons responsible for the transactions in question, as well as other sources: organisational charts, invoices, pricing and marketing policy, and others.

Importantly, the data must be up to date and therefore need to be verified each time the documentation is checked. Tax risk decreases once the actual course of the transaction has been established. The related parties must then prepare a comparability analysis, taking into account, among other things, the characteristics of the goods and services, the functions of the parties to the transaction and their economic situation, and the terms of the agreement.

Examination of transfer prices by the tax authorities

The correctness of the transfer prices set will be verified by the tax authorities. The number of stages of the examination depends on whether the authority agrees with the taxpayer's interpretation. It begins with verification activities covering the formal correctness and timeliness of the documents filed, but also their consistency with the facts. A tax audit ends with a report. If, in the opinion of the tax authorities, reality differs from what was shown in the documents, tax proceedings will be initiated.

At first instance, the correct amount of the tax liabilities will be determined. In the decision, the entity will be informed of any arrears. If the company does not agree with the decision, it may appeal – to the first-instance authority, then the second-instance authority, and even to the Voivodeship Administrative Court and the Supreme Administrative Court. The successive instances will examine only the correctness and timeliness of the procedures that took place earlier. Once the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) upholds an unfavourable decision, the taxpayer can only attempt to challenge the validity of the Polish provisions, if they are inconsistent with European ones. In such a situation there is a final instance – the European Court of Justice.

If irregularities are found, the taxpayer may face tax, fiscal penal or criminal sanctions.

What is the purpose of concluding an advance pricing agreement?

Taxpayers can make use of a very safe way of eliminating tax risk. This is the conclusion of an advance pricing agreement (APA – advance pricing arrangements ) with the Minister of Finance. It means complete security when setting transfer prices. The application must set out a proposal to apply the selected method of setting transaction prices, a description of that method in the context of the transaction, and other relevant documents and circumstances.

An agreement is concluded for a maximum period of 5 years. In Poland, however, advance pricing agreements are used exceptionally rarely, particularly because of their high price and the need to disclose a great deal of valuable information (including information originating from clients).

Transfer pricing policy – how does it reduce tax risk?

It is much easier to keep transactions compliant with tax law if all departments involved in transfer pricing matters operate in accordance with previously adopted procedures. These include a detailed transfer pricing policy. This document should contain, among other things, a list of risk-optimising procedures, the full course of the transaction, as well as definitions and a specification of the responsibilities of individuals and organisational units.

Only those enterprises that have related parties in their accounting systems are able to introduce a transfer pricing policy – a kind of tax manual. It is worth taking advantage of this option, as it is an important element of tax risk management, eliminating the possibility of related parties concluding transactions improperly.

Why does transfer pricing involve such a high risk? Because it concerns a situation in which the interests of the tax authorities and of entrepreneurs are diametrically opposed. Companies seek to optimise their tax payments and, consequently, to maximise profit. The tax administration, in turn, is to make sure that levies of the specified amount reach the state budget. The basis for avoiding problems is an excellent knowledge of the Polish and international legal regulations concerning related parties. Given how complicated the subject is, it is better to rely on professionals in this matter. So if an enterprise frequently carries out transactions with related parties, ongoing cooperation with a firm specialising in transfer pricing matters is advisable.

Related articles