Transfer pricing and international taxation
Transfer pricing rules are a tool for controlling transactions taking place between related parties. Their task is to protect equal market opportunities. Related parties are deemed to be all those companies or organisations in which one entity has a significant influence over another. This dependence may be capital-based (e.g. holding at least 25% of the shares), personal (e.g. a shared president of several entities), but also unofficial (the exertion of influence). So that entities belonging to one capital group do not favour one another when carrying out transactions, they must prove that they treat each other exactly as they would if they were dealing with any other, unrelated entity. The transfer prices applied may affect the taxes of entities whose registered offices are located in different countries. How can companies use transfer pricing for tax optimisation? And what do so-called tax havens have to do with all this?
Who creates the legal regulations for transfer pricing in international transactions?
Transfer pricing became an international issue as early as the 1960s. Initially, attention was paid to transactions between related parties operating within a single country, but as the strategy of shifting tax burdens between countries became ever more widespread, the need to control transactions concluded by entities with an international structure was quickly recognised.
Today the subject is of interest to numerous international governmental and non-governmental organisations, which have for years been engaged in creating legal standards in the area of transfer pricing.
International governmental organisations and transfer pricing
An international governmental organisation is an association of at least three states established under an international agreement. The organisation's statute sets out the purpose of its activity – it is in order to achieve that purpose that the states associate.
The international governmental organisations interested in the subject of transfer pricing and in creating regulations dedicated to it include the UN, the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) and the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum.
These organisations have regulatory functions, which allow them to lay down legal norms, control functions, which enable them to examine the solutions applied by member states against the adopted norms, as well as operational functions, expressed in the preparation of reports or the conduct of research.
International non-governmental organisations and transfer pricing
NGOs, i.e. non-governmental organisations, are subject to the law in force in the state on whose territory they were founded. They have no international legal personality and therefore cannot lay down legal norms. Their role is limited to social oversight and to exerting pressure both on states and on governmental organisations.
The international non-governmental organisations dealing with transfer pricing issues include the French Transfer Pricing Economists for Development and the Polish Transfer Pricing Centre Association.
Price setting in international capital groups
If all the entities operate in Poland, it is profitable to shift profit between entities one of which benefits from special tax reliefs. In the case of international transfers the rule is even simpler: a transaction is advantageous when it takes place between entities operating in countries with different tax rates. It should be borne in mind, however, that in the event of an audit what will be taken into account is not the profitability for the entities but the logical justification for making the transfer.
There are many entirely legitimate grounds for transactions between related parties located in different countries. A territorial division of labour may prove important, under which the individual stages of the production process take place in different countries (e.g. on account of suitable climatic conditions or the existence of a sales market in a given country). Entities may also apply a product-based division – that is, clearly specify which range of products will be manufactured in each of them (e.g. because of easier access to raw materials). A functional division, in turn, consists in locating the individual departments of an international enterprise in different parts of the world (e.g. because of the greater availability of specialists).
A well-justified transfer between related parties with registered offices in different countries may therefore translate into far more favourable taxation of the company. For this purpose it is worth verifying which taxes are imposed on products, services or goods in each of the countries.
Transfer pricing and tax havens
Tax haven is a colloquial term for a country which Polish legislation calls a “country applying harmful tax competition”. In practice this means that the state concerned imposes no taxes either on its citizens or on the entities investing in its territory, or else that such taxes are very low. This applies to income and capital taxes as well as to property taxes. What makes this solution harmful? Of course, what is meant here is not harm to the investor but to the economy of the investor's home country. Doing business in a state that levies no charges on it is, after all, profitable and is the logical choice of any entrepreneur. Driven by this motivation, companies move to tax havens, impoverishing their home economy and reducing the budget revenues of their own states.
The initial list drawn up by the Polish Ministry of Finance covers 26 countries and dependent territories that apply harmful tax competition. In 2020, 11 states whose governments are not willing to cooperate with Poland for tax purposes were added to it. The tax havens include both exotic countries (e.g. Barbados, the Republic of Nauru or the Kingdom of Tonga) and highly developed European states (e.g. Liechtenstein, Andorra, Monaco).
The 2021 amendment to the CIT Act imposes an obligation to document transactions with entities located in tax havens exceeding PLN 2,500,000 per year for financial transactions and exceeding PLN 500,000 for other transactions. In this case the law is just as strict for related parties as for unrelated ones. All companies carrying out transactions with tax havens are required to document transfer prices (with a detailed economic justification of the transaction and of the expected economic and tax benefits), to complete the TPR form (transfer pricing information) and to submit a statement on the preparation of transfer pricing documentation and on the arm's length nature of the transactions. In addition, related parties must present a transfer pricing analysis.
Any type of transaction may come under the scrutiny of the tax office: the import of goods and services from tax havens, but also exports to them, as well as the conclusion of any other transaction (e.g. a company or partnership agreement, the transfer of intangible assets, the receipt of non-current or intangible assets, the provision of services without remuneration, the making available of a trade mark, the granting or receipt of a loan, guarantee, surety or credit).
Controlling international transactions is more difficult than when all the entities under review operate within one country. That is why, from the state's point of view, it is so important that as many countries as possible introduce effective transfer pricing regulations. Particularly scrupulous scrutiny of transactions with entities from tax havens should therefore come as no surprise to entrepreneurs. As is usually the case, the only guarantee of staying out of trouble is strict compliance with the law, but also the choice of a suitable advisory firm that will help with the numerous formalities concerning related parties.
