Expert portal on transfer pricing · site owner: DMS TAX Sp. z o.o., tax advisory company
kontakt@cenytransferowe.org
Home›News›Tax proceedings at second instance

Tax proceedings at second instance

Published:

Tax proceedings at second instance, the so-called appeal proceedings, are initiated by a taxpayer who has received an unfavourable decision in the tax proceedings at first instance. An appeal against the decision of the first-instance authority is lodged through that authority within 14 days of the date of service of the contested decision. It should also be borne in mind that lodging an appeal with the second-instance authority within the prescribed time limit does not suspend enforcement of the decision of the first-instance authority.

The first-instance authority that issued the contested decision has 14 days either to issue a decision revoking the one previously issued (the self-review procedure) or to refer the case to the appeal authority. An appeal against a decision lodged through the authority should set out the objections to the decision, define the substance and scope of the request that is the subject of the appeal and indicate the evidence supporting that request.

Failure to meet the requirements laid down in the provisions of the Tax Ordinance concerning the content of the appeal or the time limit for lodging it results in the second-instance authority issuing an order closing the appeal proceedings. Such an order is final as regards the proceedings at second instance; however, a complaint against it may be lodged with the Provincial Administrative Court.

If the taxpayer has met the formal requirements, the second-instance authority re-examines the case. The proceedings before the second-instance authority are governed by the same procedural rules as cases before the first instance.

In the course of the proceedings the second-instance authority may conduct additional, supplementary evidentiary proceedings, or else revoke the contested ruling and refer the case back to the first-instance authority for re-examination.

Our experience shows that in complicated cases the second instance often extends the period for issuing a decision, as it is under no obligation to consider the appeal within a specified time limit.

In proceedings before both the first and the second instance the taxpayer may submit any evidence in support of its assertions; however, the authority’s principal evidentiary activities should be carried out in the proceedings before the first instance.

In the course of tax proceedings at second instance, the tax authority may issue the following rulings:

  • a decision upholding the decision of the first-instance authority,
  • a decision revoking the decision of the first-instance authority in whole or in part and ruling to that extent on the merits of the case,
  • a decision revoking the decision of the first-instance authority in whole or in part and discontinuing the proceedings in the case,
  • a decision discontinuing the appeal proceedings,
  • a decision revoking the decision of the first-instance authority in its entirety, by which it refers the case back to that authority for re-examination.

The taxpayer is entitled to lodge a complaint against the decision issued by the second-instance authority with the Provincial Administrative Court within 30 days of the date of service of the ruling.

Similar articles